The number that travelled
Text One: Correcting the report
An original opinion column about an error in a published community survey.
The annual report on the riverside park claimed that 48 per cent of visitors wanted longer opening hours. The correct percentage was 84 per cent. Two transposed digits had turned a clear majority into an apparent minority.
The report was not a novel, in which a reader might pause over an unexpected sentence and wonder whether it was deliberate. It was being used by people deciding what should happen to a real place. A number in a public document can travel a long way before anyone returns to its source. By the time the correction appeared, 48 per cent had already been quoted at a meeting and repeated in two newsletters.
The organisation eventually published a notice explaining the error. I was glad to see it, although quietly replacing the report would probably have been more comfortable for those responsible. A new version without an explanation might have left earlier readers believing that they had copied the number incorrectly.
There is a familiar pleasure in catching a mistake in print. It allows a critic to behave as if two reversed digits have exposed the uselessness of an entire piece of work. That conclusion is as careless as the original error. The responsible reaction is neither to ignore the wrong percentage nor to discard all the evidence around it. We should correct what is inaccurate and judge the rest on its own merits.
A public correction is therefore more than an apology. It becomes part of the information itself. It tells readers what changed and shows that accuracy is a continuing responsibility, not a promise made once when a report is published.
Text Two: The percentage I entered
An original personal article by a research assistant.
I entered 48 instead of 84. The checked summary gave the correct result, but I transposed the digits while transferring it into the report. The survey responses and calculations were accurate. My entry was not.
I discovered the mistake when a resident emailed to ask why the percentage differed so greatly from the result announced at an earlier meeting. My first reaction was to hope that a replacement could be uploaded before many people noticed. That was not a plan for making the report clear; it was a plan for escaping the sight of my own error.
We issued a new version with a note at the beginning. It stated the incorrect percentage, the correct percentage and the reason for the change. I wanted to leave out 48 because it embarrassed me, but that would have made the correction less useful. Readers who had copied the original number would have had no way to connect their notes with the revised report.
The mistake did not alter what visitors had told us. It altered what we told other people about their answers. That distinction matters, although it does not reduce my responsibility. An inaccurate percentage in a public report can influence a discussion even when it began as a private slip at a desk.
Somebody asked whether admitting the error would make the whole report appear unreliable. I cannot promise that it will not. I can say that concealing the change would ask readers to trust a document whose history we had hidden. I would rather be accountable for one corrected number than appear confident about a report that quietly changes itself.
The note now sits on the first page, above the summary, rather than at the back where only a determined reader would find it. The people who most needed it were those who had read the first version quickly. Accuracy requires attention, and trust requires honesty when attention has failed.
Compare how the writers present their ideas and perspectives about correcting mistakes in published information.
Support your answer with detailed references to both texts, including brief quotations.
324 exam-style questions on Edexcel B IGCSE English Language 2.3 Section A: Reading, covering 2.3.5 AO1 in Section A, 2.3.6 AO2 in Section A, and 2.3.7 AO3 in Section A. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.