Text One: The empty pocket
An original account by a student taking part in a school day without mobile phones.
At registration, we slid our phones into numbered fabric pouches. Mine landed with a soft thud that sounded far more final than it was. For the next six hours, I would have no timetable, camera, calculator, messages, music or weather forecast. The school called the phone a distraction. My pocket had apparently been running a small office.
Habit announced itself before first lesson. My hand checked the empty pocket at every doorway. I asked three people for the time, despite passing two clocks, and walked towards the wrong room because I was used to reading changes on a screen. Dependence was not dramatic. It consisted of tiny conveniences which I had stopped noticing.
Several adults had predicted that lunch would become wonderfully sociable. Maya produced a pack of cards and soon had six people arguing cheerfully over the rules. At the next table, however, two students studied their trays while another read the same notice twice. A screen can interrupt company, but removing it does not create friendship by itself.
The strongest argument for the day arrived in an ordinary lesson. When a paragraph became difficult, I could not invent a reason to check the time or look up a word I already understood. I underlined one sentence, then another. The work did not become exciting, but boredom had fewer doors through which to escape. The absence of a phone did not guarantee attention; it made inattention less convenient.
At the end of the day, my screen filled with a message about where I was being collected and several things which could easily have waited. I was pleased to have the phone back, but less impressed by every demand it made. I would repeat the experiment, though not as a permanent ban and not without paper timetables and reliable clocks. Taking the phone away showed me what I used it for. That was useful evidence, not a verdict.
Text Two: Attention needs somewhere to land
An original article by a teacher reflecting on a school day without mobile phones.
The most persuasive moment of our phone-free day lasted about twelve seconds. A student reached towards an empty blazer pocket, paused and returned to a difficult paragraph. Nothing spectacular followed: one sentence was underlined. Yet the student had remained with the work at precisely the point when an easier source of interest would usually have been available.
We should be careful with the word “distraction”. A phone can provide a calculator, a bus time or a photograph of unfinished work. Its usefulness is real. So is its ability to offer an exit from almost any demanding moment. The same object may be a tool at one minute and an escape route at the next.
Across the day, several lessons began more promptly because there were no arguments about devices on desks. This did not transform every student into an eager scholar, nor did the dining hall become a festival of conversation. The day altered opportunities, not personalities. Its value lay in allowing students to notice an impulse before automatically obeying it.
The experiment also exposed the school’s own dependence on phones. A room change had been posted online, some families expected to send travel arrangements during the afternoon, and staff had not provided enough alternatives to phone calculators. Students should not be blamed when an institution removes a tool without replacing the necessary functions it performed.
For that reason, I favour planned phone-free periods rather than a permanent, undifferentiated ban. Students need clear ways to receive urgent messages, access to suitable equipment and advance notice of timetable changes. With those arrangements in place, putting a phone away can become a deliberate choice about concentration rather than a display of obedience. An empty desk is not proof of learning, but it can give attention somewhere to land.
Compare how the writers present their ideas and perspectives about a school day without mobile phones.
Support your answer with detailed references to both texts, including brief quotations.
324 exam-style questions on Edexcel B IGCSE English Language 2.3 Section A: Reading, covering 2.3.5 AO1 in Section A, 2.3.6 AO2 in Section A, and 2.3.7 AO3 in Section A. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.