Text One: Working in full view
An original personal article by a baker.
For the first month, I resented the glass wall. I had trained in kitchens where the door swung shut behind the staff, and mistakes remained among the people who knew how to correct them. Here, customers could watch me misjudge the space between two trays or search three shelves for a missing cutter. I felt as if the bakery had replaced one of its walls with an audience.
The glass also exposed how little of our work resembles the photographs in cookery books. At six in the morning, there is no perfect loaf waiting beneath a cloth. There are scales to check, bowls to scrape and rows of dough that must be weighed again because the first pieces are too large. Later, when the shop fills, customers see the same movements repeated: shape, turn, place, begin again. Baking is creative, but it is also exact and tiring.
My attitude changed during a busy afternoon. A batch of dough had to return to the mixer, and a child on the other side of the glass asked her father why we were ‘starting it all over again’. He guessed that something had gone wrong. I stepped to the small opening beside the counter and explained that the dough simply needed more time. The child watched the mixer restart, then nodded as if patience were an ingredient she had not noticed before.
Being visible can still produce misunderstandings. A pause may look like idleness when I am waiting for an oven; a discarded pastry may seem careless when it has failed a safety check. We cannot explain every movement while completing the next order. Yet questions are now easier to answer because customers have seen the work that prompted them.
I no longer want the glass covered. It has not made us performers, and we should not be expected to smile through every rushed minute. What it can do is place the labour beside the finished loaf. Customers may still come for lunch rather than a lesson, but the window gives our work a presence that a neat display of products would otherwise hide.
Text Two: What the window edits out
An original design column by a workplace consultant.
‘See your bread being made,’ announces the lettering above the bakery window. It is an attractive promise. It is also a claim worth examining. Does a clear wall reveal a workplace, or does it merely create a stage on which selected tasks are allowed to appear?
Glass is not neutral. The window frames the shaping of loaves and the careful decoration of cakes because these activities are pleasant to watch. It does not show flour being unloaded before opening, trays being washed after closing or records being completed away from the counter. The customer receives a bright, silent rectangle of activity and may mistake that fragment for the whole working day.
The arrangement also changes the people being observed. Someone who knows that every hesitation is visible may hurry an unfamiliar task or avoid asking a colleague for help. A manager may intend the window to demonstrate skill, while an employee experiences it as continuous inspection. Even an interested customer cannot tell which of those interpretations is correct merely by looking.
None of this means that workplaces should be sealed from public view. Watching an object take shape can challenge the idea that it simply appears on a shelf. However, understanding requires context as well as sight. A short explanation written by the bakery team might reveal more than an uninterrupted view designed by someone else. Staff could also control a blind during training, difficult orders or particularly pressured periods.
The strongest form of openness gives workers some authority over what is shown and how it is explained. Without that authority, the window risks polishing labour into another product for the customer to consume. Transparency should help people recognise work, not require workers to remain permanently on display.
Compare how the writers present their ideas and perspectives about customers watching bakers at work through a glass wall.
Support your answer with detailed references to both texts, including brief quotations.
324 exam-style questions on Edexcel B IGCSE English Language 2.3 Section A: Reading, covering 2.3.5 AO1 in Section A, 2.3.6 AO2 in Section A, and 2.3.7 AO3 in Section A. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.