Another day of rain
Text One: The umbrella mistaken for rubbish
An original personal essay about a repaired possession.
The umbrella beside my desk was reported as rubbish before lunchtime. I could understand the mistake. Five of its panels were black, one was green, and a silver cap had replaced the original wooden tip. When it was folded, the cloth gathered unevenly around the handle. It looked less like something deliberately owned than something waiting to be removed.
There had been nothing memorable about it when I bought it. I needed an umbrella, it was raining, and the nearest shop had one left. Its history began later, with a gust that turned it inside out at a bus stop. A repairer at the market replaced a bent rib and returned the umbrella with a warning not to fight the wind next time. The advice was sensible, although it assumed that the wind accepted negotiations.
The green panel arrived after the black fabric tore against a fence. My sister had a piece of waterproof material left from another project, but no matching colour. Her repair was careful and conspicuous. Whenever the umbrella opened, the green section appeared like a flag announcing that something had happened to it.
For a while, this embarrassed me. Before an important meeting, a colleague offered to lend me a newer umbrella that looked more ‘respectable’. The word stayed with me. My own umbrella kept off the same rain, yet its repairs were being treated as evidence of neglect. In fact, they proved the opposite. Time and skill had been spent on it twice.
I began to enjoy its refusal to look new. The replacement rib clicked slightly when it opened, and the bright panel made the umbrella easy to recognise in a crowded stand. Its differences were not beautiful in the polished, shop-window sense. They were specific, and that seemed more interesting.
Eventually, the central shaft split during an entirely ordinary shower. This time the market repairer shook his head. Another temporary fix would leave the umbrella unreliable, he said. I was disappointed, but I did not ask him to perform a miracle simply to preserve my argument about repair.
The following week, I bought a plain black replacement. Doing so did not betray the old umbrella or make its repairs pointless. Mending had never promised immortality. It had returned a damaged object to use, twice, and allowed it to acquire a character no new purchase could have supplied.
Text Two: Repair is a choice, not a ceremony
An original article by the coordinator of a community repair workshop.
Applause is an unreliable measure of success in a repair workshop. People cheer when an old lamp shines again or a silent radio produces sound. They are less enthusiastic when a volunteer examines an object and advises its owner not to use it. Yet an honest refusal can be as responsible as a clever repair.
The popularity of mending is welcome. Too many useful possessions are discarded because of a loose connection, a missing screw or a torn seam. A public workshop can provide tools, practical experience and the confidence to investigate a fault. It can also make patched clothing and scratched furniture seem ordinary rather than shameful.
However, enthusiasm must not turn repair into a moral contest. Some faults cannot be corrected safely. Certain objects cannot be opened without causing further damage, while suitable replacement parts may be unavailable. A volunteer could spend an entire afternoon attempting to revive one badly damaged item when several straightforward repairs are waiting on the next table. Time and materials are limited even when nobody is charging for them.
Sentimental value complicates the decision. An object associated with a person or an important occasion may deserve an effort that makes no financial sense. That is a judgement for its owner, not a universal rule. The cracked alarm clock inherited from a grandparent and the chair bought last week may look equally repairable on the workbench, but they do not carry the same meaning.
We should also be cautious about celebrating only dramatic rescues. Maintenance is quieter and often more useful: tightening a fitting before it fails, cleaning a mechanism or reinforcing a weakening seam. These small acts attract few photographs, but they prevent possessions from reaching the repair table in the first place.
A stronger culture of repair therefore requires more than admiration for skilful volunteers. Objects need to be made so that faults can be reached, parts need to be obtainable, and owners need clear information about what can be done safely. Responsibility cannot rest entirely with the person who discovers that a sealed object has stopped working.
Repair should remain an option, not an obligation or a performance. A good workshop has a busy workbench, but it also has an exit door through which someone may carry an object that could not reasonably be saved. Knowing when to stop is part of taking repair seriously.
Compare how the writers present their ideas and perspectives about repairing everyday possessions.
Support your answer with detailed references to both texts, including brief quotations.
324 exam-style questions on Edexcel B IGCSE English Language 2.3 Section A: Reading, covering 2.3.5 AO1 in Section A, 2.3.6 AO2 in Section A, and 2.3.7 AO3 in Section A. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.