Sharing ideas at school
Source A: an original account by a school magazine editor.
At our first meeting, I placed ‘editor’ cards in front of the oldest pupils and ‘researcher’ cards in front of the youngest. It seemed an efficient way to divide the work. Leila, one of the youngest, pushed her card aside and asked why our issue about school performances contained nothing from the people who moved scenery or checked lights. Her question stopped the table. She sketched a contents page that placed those unseen jobs at its centre, and the group chose it over my plan. The card I had given her was smaller than the part she was ready to play. We now listen to everyone’s proposal before deciding who will lead each section.
Source B: an original account by a pupil attending a writing workshop.
I expected the visiting poet to unlock the poem like a cupboard and hand us its meaning. Instead, she read two lines and asked what we heard in them. I was annoyed: the poet had handed our question back unopened. Then one pupil heard an argument in the lines, while another heard a lullaby, and both pointed to particular words. The poet did not choose a winner. On the bus home, I was still testing the two interpretations against each other. I had learnt more from a question left open than from an answer closed.
Compare how the writers’ experiences change their views about who has useful ideas to offer.
In your answer, you could write about:
Use evidence from both sources.
140 exam-style questions on AQA GCSE English Language 3.1 Critical reading and comprehension, covering 3.1.1 Identify and interpret themes, ideas and information, 3.1.2 Read in different ways for different purposes, 3.1.3 Draw inferences and justify with evidence, 3.1.4 Support a point of view using textual evidence, 3.1.5 Identify bias and misuse of evidence, 3.1.6 Reflect critically and evaluatively using context, 3.1.7 Recognise different responses to a text, 3.1.8 Identify the main theme or themes, 3.1.9 Summarise ideas and information from a single text, 3.1.10 Synthesise from more than one text, 3.1.11 Explain how vocabulary and grammar create impact, 3.1.12 Analyse and evaluate form and structure, and 3.1.13 Compare texts critically. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.