Restoring the town clock
Source A: an original letter from a shopkeeper.
For six weeks, the clock above the square has insisted that it is quarter past nine. People leaving my shop look up before walking to the coach stop, then come back to ask me for the correct time. The restoration should make the clock dependable again and light the face after dusk. Whether every old cog remains hidden inside the tower matters less to me than having a clock that the whole town can actually use.
Source B: an original letter from a local historian.
I climbed the clock tower while researching the town archive. Inside, brass plates carry the names of the local apprentices who maintained the mechanism over many years. Replacing it with a sealed modern unit would make the hands move, but it would discard that record of skill. Accuracy matters, and I would not object to a discreet light, but the original mechanism should be repaired rather than removed. The clock must not become merely a new machine behind an old face.
Using details from both sources, infer how the shopkeeper's priorities for the restoration differ from the local historian's.
140 exam-style questions on AQA GCSE English Language 3.1 Critical reading and comprehension, covering 3.1.1 Identify and interpret themes, ideas and information, 3.1.2 Read in different ways for different purposes, 3.1.3 Draw inferences and justify with evidence, 3.1.4 Support a point of view using textual evidence, 3.1.5 Identify bias and misuse of evidence, 3.1.6 Reflect critically and evaluatively using context, 3.1.7 Recognise different responses to a text, 3.1.8 Identify the main theme or themes, 3.1.9 Summarise ideas and information from a single text, 3.1.10 Synthesise from more than one text, 3.1.11 Explain how vocabulary and grammar create impact, 3.1.12 Analyse and evaluate form and structure, and 3.1.13 Compare texts critically. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.