The town clock
Source A: an original account by a clock repairer.
Inside the tower, every brass wheel carries the faint marks of the person who shaped it. The mechanism now loses several minutes each week, but that does not make it worthless. These parts have worked together for nearly two centuries; replacing them would turn a difficult repair into an easy disposal. Restoring the clock properly will take months of testing, followed by regular winding and patient maintenance. That continuing responsibility is part of preserving it. A town should not claim to value its history only when history is convenient.
Source B: an original account by a market trader.
From my stall, I watch visitors glance up at a clock face covered by scaffolding. The reopening date has already been delayed twice, while traders explain that nobody knows when the work will finish. I remember hearing the clock strike when I came to the market as a child, so of course its history matters to me. However, the market needs more than a treasured object hidden inside a tower. It needs a clock that people can see, hear and depend upon, particularly on busy market days.
The council proposes restoring the original mechanism and training volunteers to wind it each week. This would postpone the reopening from this spring until next autumn.
What can you infer about the support and reservations each writer might express about the council’s proposal? Use details from both sources.
140 exam-style questions on AQA GCSE English Language 3.1 Critical reading and comprehension, covering 3.1.1 Identify and interpret themes, ideas and information, 3.1.2 Read in different ways for different purposes, 3.1.3 Draw inferences and justify with evidence, 3.1.4 Support a point of view using textual evidence, 3.1.5 Identify bias and misuse of evidence, 3.1.6 Reflect critically and evaluatively using context, 3.1.7 Recognise different responses to a text, 3.1.8 Identify the main theme or themes, 3.1.9 Summarise ideas and information from a single text, 3.1.10 Synthesise from more than one text, 3.1.11 Explain how vocabulary and grammar create impact, 3.1.12 Analyse and evaluate form and structure, and 3.1.13 Compare texts critically. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.