The altered island crossing
Source A: an original contemporary non-fiction-style account.
Our local history project had arranged a two-day visit to an island archive. A week before departure, the project coordinator sent us ferry times, room bookings and a timetable showing when each person could examine the documents. My task was to study several maps, and I had planned the order carefully. At seven on the morning of the journey, however, the ferry company cancelled our sailing because of strong winds. I assumed the visit was over. Within an hour, the coordinator had moved our archive appointment, confirmed that the hostel would hold our rooms and instructed us to meet for the afternoon ferry instead.
When we eventually landed, the minibus that should have collected us was missing because its driver had broken down. The coordinator told us to wait in the harbour café while she telephoned the island office and arranged another vehicle. I would have preferred to start walking, but separating the group would have made the revised archive appointment harder to manage. On arrival, we discovered that a leaking pipe had closed the main reading room. Only four people could work in the smaller room, so the coordinator sent two of us to interview residents until space became available. My maps remained unopened while I listened to an elderly fisherman describe the former harbour.
Fog cancelled our return ferry the next evening. Again, the coordinator extended the room bookings and transferred our tickets while the rest of us waited for instructions. Her arrangements prevented every setback from becoming six separate problems. They also meant that my own plan survived only in fragments. I completed less map research than intended, yet returned with an interview I would never have arranged for myself. The journey was secure and productive, although many of its decisions no longer belonged to me.
Source B: an original letter in a nineteenth-century voice. This is a period-voice simulation, not an archival document.
Dear Margaret, I have returned from St Oran's Island, though very little occurred according to my design. I had written to the churchwarden to say that I wished to copy the inscriptions in the old church, but no answer reached me before I left. The master of the boat had agreed to land me at the western pier. Once we were at sea, he judged the wind too troublesome there and put me ashore at a quarry cove on the southern side instead. He said that he might collect me at dusk, provided the water became calmer.
I now required a route across the island. A fisherman recommended the cliff road because it was short, while the woman at the quarry store warned that part of it had fallen away and advised the inland track. There was nobody appointed to settle the matter, so I chose the longer way. At the church I found the door locked and the churchwarden absent. A shepherd directed me to the blacksmith, who knew that the churchwarden's sister kept another key. Through these separate acts of assistance I entered at last, although half the afternoon had been spent obtaining what one confirmed arrangement might have provided.
The boat did not appear at dusk. A widow offered me a bed, while a carrier believed that a supply boat would leave from the eastern cove early the next morning. I accepted the room and then walked to the cove before breakfast to ask for passage. Everyone I met was generous, but each person could answer only the immediate question before me. I was free to alter my intentions and grateful for local knowledge, yet I remained responsible for deciding which advice to trust and what to do if it failed.
Using both sources, summarise what you understand about the different ways in which other people shape the writers' decisions when their original plans are disrupted.
508 exam-style questions on AQA GCSE English Language 6.2 Content, covering 6.2.1 Reading sources: non-fiction and literary non-fiction, 6.2.2 Time periods of the sources, 6.2.3 Choice of genre, and 6.2.4 Section B writing task. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.