Removing an old tree
Source A: an original contemporary non-fiction-style account.
I had used the old tree in the town square as a meeting place for years, so I was suspicious when the council announced that it would be removed. The notice referred to raised paving and a branch damaged during strong winds. I assumed that public safety was simply a neat phrase used to prevent an argument.
A week later, I watched the work begin. One of the crew showed us where the damaged branch had split. When it was lowered, the break ran deep into the wood. I could no longer pretend that age and strength were the same thing. Removing the tree seemed necessary, but necessity did not make the decision cheerful.
The square afterwards was painfully bright. The bench stood without shade, and the three replacement trees looked as thin as walking sticks. They may eventually grow into the space, but promises about twenty years from now do not improve next summer. Safety may explain a loss without making that loss feel small. If an old tree must go, those responsible should replace more than the object itself: they should consider the shelter, character and memories that disappear with it.
Source B: an original letter in a nineteenth-century voice. This is a period-voice simulation, not an archival document.
Sir, the committee proposes to fell the great tree beside the market so that carts may pass through the square more quickly. Its roots are described as troublesome and its branches as untidy. These are curious accusations to make against something that has occupied its place longer than any member of the committee.
Three generations have waited beneath that tree for friends, sheltered there from rain and rested there during the heat of market day. The committee counts the minutes a driver might save, but not the years of public usefulness it intends to destroy. A damaged limb may be cut away, and the paving may be repaired. It does not follow that the whole tree should be sacrificed to impatience.
We are often told that improvement requires courage. Sometimes it requires the courage to leave a valuable thing where it stands. Let carts take the wider street, and let the committee spend its energy preserving what cannot quickly be replaced. A town that removes every inconvenience may discover that it has also removed its character.
Refer to the whole of both sources. Compare the writers’ perspectives on removing old trees from public places and how they convey those perspectives. Support your comparison with evidence from both sources.
508 exam-style questions on AQA GCSE English Language 6.2 Content, covering 6.2.1 Reading sources: non-fiction and literary non-fiction, 6.2.2 Time periods of the sources, 6.2.3 Choice of genre, and 6.2.4 Section B writing task. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.