Learning shorthand
Source A: an original contemporary non-fiction-style account.
I joined the evening shorthand course because ordinary handwriting could not keep pace with meetings at work. The class met every Tuesday in a quiet room at the college. There were ten learners, all seated at separate desks facing a clock. Our tutor introduced the shorthand symbols in small groups and gave us printed passages containing only the forms we had already studied. At first, she dictated slowly enough for us to think before making each mark.
The pace increased over the ten weeks, but it was measured rather than guessed. The tutor announced the speed before every exercise and read each passage twice. Afterwards, we exchanged the shorthand notes for the original text and marked where words had been lost or confused. She collected one exercise from each learner and added individual comments before the following lesson. Recordings were also supplied for practice at home, where they could be paused and repeated.
My early pages were crowded with corrections, yet nobody needed the information I had failed to capture. An error simply showed which symbol required more practice. By the final week I could follow a short passage at the target speed, although unfamiliar words still delayed me. The steady increase had allowed difficulty to arrive in stages. I was not learning while somebody waited for an accurate account of an event; accuracy itself was the lesson.
Source B: an original letter in a nineteenth-century voice. This is a period-voice simulation, not an archival document.
Dear Thomas, my work at the newspaper office has persuaded me to learn shorthand, for the editor speaks more rapidly than any ordinary pen can travel. There is no appointed lesson. Mr Price, the senior clerk, has shown me several useful signs and lends me his old notebook when he does not require it. I copy the marks during quieter moments, though such moments cannot be relied upon.
My real practice occurs when the editor calls from his room and dictates a report or public notice. Messages arrive, visitors ask questions and the printing machinery below us makes the floor tremble. The editor seldom states how quickly he intends to speak. If I ask him to repeat a sentence, he may do so, but his patience shortens when the printers are waiting for the copy. I must then turn my notes into ordinary writing while I can still remember what the missing marks were meant to contain.
Mr Price checks my finished copy and points out omissions, but by then the error has already delayed the work. This is a severe method of learning, although it has made me attend closely. The words are not selected because they suit the signs I know, and no passage is delivered twice merely for practice. On a calm afternoon I may record almost everything; during a busy morning, interruption and haste defeat me. My education advances at the speed required by the office rather than at a speed chosen for a beginner.
Drawing on both sources, summarise what you understand about the differences in the conditions under which the writers learn shorthand.
508 exam-style questions on AQA GCSE English Language 6.2 Content, covering 6.2.1 Reading sources: non-fiction and literary non-fiction, 6.2.2 Time periods of the sources, 6.2.3 Choice of genre, and 6.2.4 Section B writing task. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.