Source A: an original contemporary non-fiction-style account.
Before my first sailing lesson, I had pictured myself sitting calmly in a white boat while the wind performed the difficult work. The instructor corrected this idea before we had left the shore. There were ropes to hold, instructions to remember and a low metal bar that seemed determined to cross the boat whenever my attention wandered. I had expected elegance. What I experienced was a series of urgent decisions made while crouching.
The first gust pushed the boat sideways and tipped it until the water appeared alarmingly close. I gripped the edge. The instructor continued speaking in the same tone she had used on land, which was either reassuring or evidence that she had failed to notice our approaching disaster. She told me to loosen one rope. The boat settled at once, making my panic look unnecessarily theatrical.
Later, when I took control, I began to feel the boat respond. It did not obey in the simple way a machine obeys a switch. A small movement altered our direction; a pause allowed the wind to move us faster than effort could. For several minutes, we travelled without noise except for water brushing the hull. The silence felt earned because it followed so much clumsy activity.
I returned to shore wet, tired and pleased. I had not mastered the wind, and I no longer thought mastery was the point. Sailing seemed less like issuing orders and more like maintaining a conversation in which the other participant could leave whenever it wished. I booked another lesson because uncertainty had become interesting rather than merely frightening.
Source B: an original letter in a nineteenth-century voice. This is a period-voice simulation, not an archival document.
My dear Anne, I must tell you of our passage across the bay, since Thomas has already written to Mother and will certainly make me appear more sensible than I was. The morning was so mild that I treated his concern about the weather as needless caution. Our little boat moved neatly from the harbour, answering the rudder like a well-trained horse, and I congratulated myself on skills that the calm water had not yet tested.
Halfway across, the wind failed completely. We sat beneath a slack sail while the island seemed to remain exactly where it was, however long we watched it. I found this delay amusing and gave Thomas a speech about patience. Soon afterwards, a dark line crossed the water. The sail filled with a crack, the boat leaned sharply and my excellent speech was forgotten.
Thomas lowered the sail while I removed water with a tin cup. Neither task was noble, but both became urgent. The bay that had looked polished and harmless from the harbour now seemed full of separate movements, each indifferent to our plans. We reached the island thoroughly wet. The fisherman who secured our rope showed no surprise at our condition, which injured my pride more effectively than any lecture.
I do not mean to become timid. Indeed, I should like to make the journey again. But I shall not mistake favourable weather for personal ability, nor call another man's caution fear merely because I wish to depart. The sea had not been defeated by our arrival. It had permitted two foolish travellers to learn something and return safely enough to describe it.
Use the whole of both sources. Compare how the writers convey their perspectives on sailing in a small boat. In your answer, you should:
508 exam-style questions on AQA GCSE English Language 6.2 Content, covering 6.2.1 Reading sources: non-fiction and literary non-fiction, 6.2.2 Time periods of the sources, 6.2.3 Choice of genre, and 6.2.4 Section B writing task. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.