Making room for old trees
Source A: an original contemporary non-fiction-style account.
When a bright mark appeared on the oldest tree in our road, I treated it as a sentence already passed. The tree had stood outside the corner shop for longer than any resident could remember. Its branches softened the view of the flats, and its roots had pushed the pavement into small hills that children used as starting lines for races. By evening, a campaign to save it had begun.
At the council meeting, the situation became less simple. A wheelchair user described being forced into the road where the pavement narrowed. The shopkeeper showed photographs of a heavy branch that had fallen before opening time. I had arrived prepared to defend the tree from people and found that people also needed defending from our easy certainty.
The final plan was neither immediate removal nor careless neglect. The pavement would curve around the trunk, damaged branches would be reduced and the tree would be inspected regularly. If it became unsafe, a replacement would be planted before it was removed. Age is an argument for careful thought, not immunity from every practical question. Keeping an old tree should mean making responsible room for it, not demanding that everyone else accepts the difficulties in silence.
Source B: an original letter in a nineteenth-century voice. This is a period-voice simulation, not an archival document.
Dear Henry, The improvements to West Street are nearly complete, and the change is remarkable. Several ancient trees, which formerly crowded the road and darkened the lower rooms, have been removed. The way is now broad enough for carts to pass without dispute, and young trees have been planted at regular distances. Their straight lines give the street an order it never possessed before.
Some inhabitants complain that the place has lost its character. I confess that the new avenue appears rather bare, and the saplings offer little shelter at present. Yet a town cannot refuse every alteration merely because an inconvenience has become familiar. Trees exist among houses and traffic; they cannot be considered as though the street had remained an empty field.
I am pleased, however, that the great beech beside the inn has been spared. It obstructs no doorway, and travellers have long used it as a sign that they are approaching the town. To remove it for the sake of perfect regularity would exchange memory for neatness without gaining anything useful. Old trees should remain where they continue to serve a place, but age alone cannot give each trunk a permanent claim upon a changing street.
You should consider the whole of both sources. Compare the writers’ attitudes towards keeping old trees in growing towns and the ways they communicate those attitudes. Use evidence from Source A and Source B in your response.
508 exam-style questions on AQA GCSE English Language 6.2 Content, covering 6.2.1 Reading sources: non-fiction and literary non-fiction, 6.2.2 Time periods of the sources, 6.2.3 Choice of genre, and 6.2.4 Section B writing task. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.