Watching skilled work
Source A: a newly written contemporary non-fiction-style account.
I booked a place at the map-repair workshop expecting a satisfying before-and-after rescue. On the central table lay a coastal map damaged by water: its paper was wrinkled, its colours interrupted by pale gaps. Yet for the first twenty minutes, the conservator did not repair anything. She examined the edges, adjusted the light and recorded each stain. I became impatient. The most skilful action appeared to be postponement.
She then pointed to a missing section of blue line and asked whether we thought it should be redrawn. Some visitors wanted the map made complete; others argued that a new line would pretend to be old. After listening, the conservator said, “You are helping us identify what needs explaining. You are not deciding the treatment.” At first, this felt like an invitation withdrawn just as the discussion became interesting. Gradually, however, I understood that a vote would have replaced a difficult judgement with a confident show of hands. We were useful because our disagreement exposed the problem, not because we could solve it. I left without the dramatic transformation I had expected, but with greater respect for decisions that remain visible as decisions.
Source B: a newly written letter using a nineteenth-century voice. It is not an archival document.
Sir, yesterday I visited a printing office whose proprietor was eager to demonstrate the speed of his establishment. The great machine thundered below us, swallowing blank paper and delivering printed sheets in such numbers that the company applauded. I confess that I shared their astonishment. The noise did our thinking for us: anything so rapid and forceful appeared unquestionably clever.
We were afterwards taken through an upper room where several workers arranged and inspected the type. Here there was little movement worth displaying. One man studied a single line for some time before removing a letter that had been placed incorrectly. Our guide urged us onward, observing that there was “nothing to see”, but I thought the opposite. We had been shown the power by which words are multiplied and had nearly missed the patience by which an error is prevented from multiplying with them. The public may admire a machine without understanding the labour it depends upon. We were shown nearly everything in the office except, until that quiet moment, the nature of its work.
Using evidence from across both sources, compare the writers’ perspectives on what makes watching skilled work valuable and the methods they use to present those perspectives.
508 exam-style questions on AQA GCSE English Language 6.2 Content, covering 6.2.1 Reading sources: non-fiction and literary non-fiction, 6.2.2 Time periods of the sources, 6.2.3 Choice of genre, and 6.2.4 Section B writing task. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.