The park after sunset
Source A: a contemporary first-person article.
Until last summer, I treated the park gates as a finishing line. If I was not through them before sunset, I hurried home by the main road instead. The park after dark existed in my imagination as a place of hidden paths and alarming noises.
Then the council began keeping the gates open until ten during the warmer months. On the first evening, I entered cautiously and found the paths lit by low lamps. A runner passed me, followed by two nurses still wearing their work uniforms. Near the pond, a family was sharing food while an elderly man studied the water through a pair of binoculars. The park had not become dangerous when daylight faded; it had simply become available to different people.
Of course, open gates alone are not enough. Broken lights must be repaired quickly, bushes beside paths should be kept low and staff should remain visible. These measures do not restrict freedom: they make freedom possible. People who work long hours, live in small flats or find busy streets exhausting deserve access to open space too.
I still listen more carefully when I walk there at night. Caution is sensible. Fear, however, should not be allowed to lock a public place before many residents have had the chance to use it.
Source B: a letter written in a nineteenth-century style. This is an original simulation, not a historical document.
Sir,
I have learned that the town committee proposes to leave the gates of the public park unlocked after nightfall. I hope that this plan will be reconsidered. The park is a cheerful refuge by day, when children play under the observation of their families and visitors may admire the flower beds. Darkness alters its character.
The committee argues that later hours would benefit working people. I respect this intention, but the park cannot be made suitable for every purpose at every hour. Plants recently damaged by careless feet require protection, and the keeper cannot reasonably be expected to patrol every path until late at night. Lamps would add expense while illuminating only small circles of ground, leaving the spaces between them uncertain.
Closing the gates is not an act of hostility towards the public. It allows the gardeners to preserve what the public comes to enjoy. A library is valuable although its doors do not stand open throughout the night; the same principle should apply here. Let the park welcome all citizens from morning until dusk, but let quiet and careful maintenance follow.
A public possession is not protected by granting unlimited access to it. Sometimes a boundary is the means by which a shared place remains worthy of sharing.
Both writers discuss whether a public park should remain open after daylight has faded. Compare their viewpoints and the ways they communicate them. Use evidence from across Source A and Source B.
To help organise your response, you may consider:
508 exam-style questions on AQA GCSE English Language 6.2 Content, covering 6.2.1 Reading sources: non-fiction and literary non-fiction, 6.2.2 Time periods of the sources, 6.2.3 Choice of genre, and 6.2.4 Section B writing task. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.