The weighbridge proposal
Source A: an original contemporary non-fiction-style account.
When the council first proposed replacing the old public weighbridge, I supported it. Its platform was awkward to reach, and the new one promised a level approach and a sheltered place to wait. I thought the argument was simple: keep what still worked, improve what did not.
Then the notice appeared with a date for the old structure’s removal. People I had never seen at a council meeting began stopping beside it. A farmer showed me the pencil marks his father had made on its wooden post; a delivery driver remembered learning to read the dial there with his mother. I had treated the weighbridge as equipment. To them it was also a record of ordinary work.
I still want a safer, more usable platform. But I no longer think replacement has to mean erasure. At the next meeting I asked whether the old dial and post could be kept beside the new platform, with their stories recorded. The council has not decided. I went home less certain of my first answer, but more certain that a practical improvement should leave room for what people already value.
Source B: an original letter in a nineteenth-century voice. This is a period-voice simulation, not an archival document.
Dear Sir, I was at first well content to hear that the town would have a new weighing machine. The old one has served long, but the beam is slow to settle and the figures are difficult to read in poor light. A sounder instrument would spare much dispute between seller and buyer.
Yet the proposed site is beyond the market square, where few pass except those with business at the yard. I had supposed a machine to be no more than iron and measure. On the morning the notice was read, an old carrier told how, at this very place, he had weighed the first load he was trusted to take alone. Others spoke of bargains settled and news exchanged while the beam came to rest. Their accounts made me see that the present position has its own usefulness, not all of it reckoned in weight.
I do not withdraw my support for a better machine; nor would I have a faulty measure preserved for sentiment. But the new instrument should stand where people can still meet, and the old dial might be set up nearby. We may mend the measure without pretending that the place has been empty of meaning.
Refer to the whole of both sources. Compare the writers’ perspectives on the proposed replacement of the weighbridge, how those perspectives develop as the plans take shape and how the writers convey them. Support your comparison with evidence from both sources.
508 exam-style questions on AQA GCSE English Language 6.2 Content, covering 6.2.1 Reading sources: non-fiction and literary non-fiction, 6.2.2 Time periods of the sources, 6.2.3 Choice of genre, and 6.2.4 Section B writing task. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.