Offering advice
Source A: an original contemporary non-fiction-style account.
When my younger brother asked whether he should move to another town for work, I treated the question as an invitation to take charge. Within an hour, I had compared rents, calculated journey times and produced a firm conclusion. He listened until I reached the section headed “long-term prospects”, then said, rather quietly, that he had wanted to discuss the decision, not receive a committee report about his own life.
Since then, I have tried to make advice smaller. I begin by asking which part of the problem feels difficult. If my experience is relevant, I offer it as an example rather than a prediction. Advice should help someone see the paths available; it should not push them down the path I would choose. The hardest part is allowing a person to hear my opinion and still decide differently. Yet advice that comes with a demand for obedience is merely control wearing a helpful expression.
Source B: an original letter in a nineteenth-century voice. This is a period-voice simulation, not an archival document.
Dear Clara, do not suppose that friendship requires us to remain silent whenever the truth may be unwelcome. A person standing near a danger may perceive it more clearly than the person approaching it. Experience would be a selfish possession if we refused to share its warnings merely because we feared appearing severe.
Nevertheless, counsel must never be confused with command. First discover what your friend values, or you may solve a difficulty that exists only in your own imagination. State your reasons plainly, but do not repeat them until affection begins to resemble a siege. Place a lamp at the turning; do not seize the traveller by the sleeve. Once advice has been honestly given, the choice belongs to the person who must live with its consequences. If that choice differs from yours, friendship should not be withdrawn as a punishment.
Using the whole of both sources, compare the writers’ perspectives on giving advice and the methods they use to present those perspectives. Support your response with evidence from both sources.
508 exam-style questions on AQA GCSE English Language 6.2 Content, covering 6.2.1 Reading sources: non-fiction and literary non-fiction, 6.2.2 Time periods of the sources, 6.2.3 Choice of genre, and 6.2.4 Section B writing task. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.