Choosing a winner
Source A: an original contemporary non-fiction-style account.
When I agreed to judge the cake competition at our neighbourhood fair, I expected a pleasant afternoon and a neat answer. Twelve cakes stood in a row beneath clear covers. We had score sheets with separate boxes for appearance, texture and flavour. The numbers looked reassuringly precise, like marks on a ruler.
Precision did not survive the first mouthful. One cake rose perfectly but tasted ordinary. Another had sunk in the middle, yet its sharp lemon filling made all three judges reach for a second piece. We praised a fruit cake for being traditional and a chocolate cake for being inventive, then realised that we were rewarding opposite qualities. Our scores disagreed so widely that we rubbed them out and began discussing what we actually valued.
Eventually, we gave the rosette to a simple fruit cake whose flavour and texture impressed us all. The decision was reasonable, but it was not a scientific fact. After the announcement, visitors gathered around the winning cake for a few minutes. Then every entry was sliced and passed along the tables. The uneven lemon cake disappeared first.
A competition can encourage people to take care and can give a fair a sense of occasion. However, a score sheet should not masquerade as a machine for measuring taste. By the end of the afternoon, the rosette was still bright, but the sheet beside it was spotted with crumbs. That seemed the more honest picture: one winner, several good cakes and a judgement open to discussion.
Source B: an original letter in a nineteenth-century voice. This is a period-voice simulation, not an archival document.
Dear Brother, Yesterday I entered my model of a wooden bridge in the town's exhibition of useful arts. For months I had imagined the prize medal hanging above my workbench. When it was placed beside another man's model, my disappointment was immediate and severe. I had thought my bridge both strong and handsome, and I wished to know why it had failed.
One of the judges invited me to watch the models being tested. Under the third iron weight, a narrow support in mine began to bend. The winning bridge carried another weight without movement. Its maker had used less wood than I had, but had placed each piece more wisely. The judge did not attempt to comfort me. He pointed to the bending support and said, “There is your lesson.”
Those words were more useful than sympathy. I spent the rest of the exhibition measuring the successful model and making notes while other visitors examined my own. I had entered hoping that a medal would declare my education complete. Instead, the absence of one showed me exactly where my knowledge was weak.
I do not pretend that losing pleased me, nor do I think every judge must be correct. Yet a prize has value when it directs attention towards work that can withstand examination. I carried no medal home, but I carried a page of measurements and a plan for a stronger bridge. Defeat, on this occasion, proved to be information rather than disgrace.
Use the whole of both sources.
Compare the writers' perspectives on competitions and judging, and how they convey these perspectives.
In your response, compare:
Support your comparison with evidence from both sources.
508 exam-style questions on AQA GCSE English Language 6.2 Content, covering 6.2.1 Reading sources: non-fiction and literary non-fiction, 6.2.2 Time periods of the sources, 6.2.3 Choice of genre, and 6.2.4 Section B writing task. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.