A council is choosing a waterproof covering for the roof of a new library. The library is expected to be used for 60 years.
The aluminium covering is made from aluminium extracted from its ore. The polymer covering is made from crude oil.
The table gives data for one complete roof covering.
| Life-cycle information | Aluminium sheets | Polymer membrane |
|---|---|---|
| energy to obtain raw materials / GJ | 220 | 40 |
| energy to manufacture the covering / GJ | 60 | 70 |
| expected working life / years | 60 | 20 |
| material recycled at the end of each working life / % | 92 | 18 |
For the first covering, obtaining the raw materials and manufacturing the aluminium sheets requires 170 GJ more energy than for the polymer membrane.
Over 60 years, the aluminium roof requires one covering and uses 280 GJ for raw materials and manufacture. The polymer roof requires three coverings and uses 330 GJ for raw materials and manufacture.
Evaluate the use of aluminium sheets rather than a polymer membrane for the library roof. Use the information given.
121 exam-style questions on Edexcel GCSE Chemistry 5.1 Obtaining and using metals, covering 5.1.1 The reactivity series of metals, 5.1.2 Displacement reactions as redox reactions, 5.1.3 Extracting metals from ores by reduction, 5.1.4 Biological methods of metal extraction, 5.1.5 Resistance to oxidation and recycling metals, and 5.1.6 Life cycle assessment. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.