Source A: an original imagined account by a visitor using a live route-status map at a country park.
At the entrance, a screen marked each walking route green, amber or red according to recent use. I had expected to follow the path to the viewpoint, but its red line confirmed what I could already see: people were leaving in a steady procession. The green route through the alder trees gave me another choice without requiring me to inspect every path first.
For ten minutes, the map appeared to have rescued the walk. Then three families arrived behind me, each explaining that green had directed them there. The information had not merely described the route; it had advertised it. A status which was accurate when I entered the park was creating its own inaccuracy.
The word attached to the colour mattered too. The screen called the route quiet, but numbers cannot measure every kind of disturbance. Twelve walkers spread along a path might barely notice one another, while a single large group could fill it with conversation. I would keep the map because it replaced guesswork with evidence, but I would describe what had actually been recorded. “Fewer walkers reported twenty minutes ago” is less attractive than “quiet”, but it does not pretend to promise an experience.
Source B: an original imagined explanation by a ranger responsible for the route-status map.
The map was introduced to spread visitors across several routes and reduce pressure on the most frequently used paths. It also allows people to choose according to their own priorities. Someone seeking a direct walk may accept a busy route, while another visitor may prefer a longer alternative with fewer people recorded.
The colours summarise recent information rather than predict what a person will encounter. If several visitors respond to a green route at once, its condition may change before the next update. That does not make the earlier information false, but it does mean that the time of the update must be prominent.
Displaying only raw totals would create another difficulty. Twenty people on a broad track do not have the same effect as twenty people on a narrow path, so visitors cannot compare figures without some knowledge of each route. Clear categories remain useful for quick decisions, provided that the map explains what they represent and does not describe green routes as guaranteed to be peaceful.
The map cannot distribute people perfectly, and it should never replace temporary instructions from staff. Its value lies in improving a choice, not making the choice on a visitor’s behalf.
Compare the visitor’s and ranger’s views on how useful the map is when choosing a walk.
809 exam-style questions on Oxford AQA IGCSE English Language 5.1 AO1: Reading, covering 5.1.1 R1: Read and understand texts, 5.1.2 R2: Collate and synthesise across sources, 5.1.3 R3: Develop and sustain interpretations, and 5.1.4 R4: Explain and evaluate writers' use of features. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.