The pencil line in the borrowed book
Source A: an original imagined contribution by a reader who enjoys finding annotations in borrowed books.
When I open a borrowed novel and discover a sentence marked in pencil, I do not immediately see damage. The mark tells me that another reader paused there, and a short comment can offer a second way into a passage. Sometimes the stranger in the margin has noticed a connection I would have missed.
That does not mean I want every page crowded with instructions about what to think. I prefer notes that leave room for disagreement. A question, an explanation or a date can add something to the life of a book without taking my own response away from me.
A clean page is certainly easier to enter, but it is not always more interesting. I like the suggestion that a book has travelled through other minds, provided the traces remain modest enough for the next reader to make the book their own.
Source B: an original imagined contribution by a reader who prefers unmarked pages.
I want the first conversation in a book to be between the printed words and me. An underline made by someone else can turn an ordinary sentence into an instruction to admire it, while a comment in the margin can interrupt a scene before I have decided what it means.
I understand why a brief explanation might help when a reader is puzzled, and I can imagine that a dated inscription would interest someone studying a book's past. In a book being passed from one ordinary reader to another, though, I would rather not receive either person's running commentary.
For me, an unmarked page is not empty or without a history. It is an open space in which a new reader can notice different things. The book may still have travelled widely; its earlier journeys do not need to be written across the words.
Compare the views in Sources A and B about handwritten annotations in borrowed books.
809 exam-style questions on Oxford AQA IGCSE English Language 5.1 AO1: Reading, covering 5.1.1 R1: Read and understand texts, 5.1.2 R2: Collate and synthesise across sources, 5.1.3 R3: Develop and sustain interpretations, and 5.1.4 R4: Explain and evaluate writers' use of features. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.