The line around the bowl
An original literary non-fiction-style account of repairing a damaged ceramic bowl at a community workshop.
The tutor placed a cracked bowl in front of each of us. Mine had broken into three pieces, although somebody had already fitted them together loosely. A pale line circled the bowl like a route drawn on a globe. I asked where the matching paint was kept. The tutor said we would think about colour later; first, the bowl had to stand steadily and hold a handful of wooden counters.
I had imagined carrying home an object which appeared never to have been broken. I pressed the first two pieces together and wiped the join repeatedly, trying to remove every trace of adhesive. Each time I cleaned one section, another slipped. When I finally placed the bowl on the table, it rocked beneath my finger.
Across from me, a man was repairing a small blue jug. He had made no attempt to disguise a missing chip near its base. Instead, he had filled the space with a dark material which made the damaged area more noticeable. I thought the patch looked like an interruption. Then he turned the jug slowly and showed me the worn marks where his grandmother's rings had struck it while she arranged flowers. The new patch did not pretend to be one of those marks, but neither did it erase them.
I joined my bowl again, this time leaving the pale line alone while I concentrated on aligning its base. The tutor poured in the wooden counters and asked me to lift it a few centimetres above the table. Nothing moved. The visible join suddenly seemed less like evidence of failure and more like evidence that the bowl had survived one.
My confidence lasted until I picked up a cup with a repaired handle. The handle shifted under my thumb. Its owner said the gap gave it character, but the tutor asked him to imagine somebody lifting a hot drink with it. He removed the handle and began again. I looked back at my bowl and tested each join once more.
At home, I put the bowl on a shelf with the repaired line facing into the room. I did not think every crack deserved to become a decoration, and I would not have trusted that loose handle. Yet turning the line towards the wall would have made the repair answer only the question I had brought to the workshop: can the damage be hidden? The bowl now answered a more useful question as well: can the object carry what it is meant to carry?
Explain how the contrasting experiences of the jug and cup shape the narrator's decision to display the bowl's repaired line.
809 exam-style questions on Oxford AQA IGCSE English Language 5.1 AO1: Reading, covering 5.1.1 R1: Read and understand texts, 5.1.2 R2: Collate and synthesise across sources, 5.1.3 R3: Develop and sustain interpretations, and 5.1.4 R4: Explain and evaluate writers' use of features. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.