At the residents’ meeting, the proposal was to move the bench from beneath the plane tree to the paved space beside the garden gate. I had sat on it often enough to think of it as part of the tree. The notice called the move an improvement, which seemed a tidy word for taking something away.
On Saturday I went back to look. Mr Hales was on the bench, sorting the post in his coat pocket. He said he came there each morning because he could see the bus turn at the end of the road. A little girl was using the seat to tie her shoelace while her father held two shopping bags. Neither of them seemed to be waiting for anything. The bench had the worn shine of a place people found without arranging to meet.
Then a woman came along the garden path in a wheelchair. Where the path narrowed beside the bench, under a low branch, she stopped, tried to turn and had to reverse towards the gate. She said nothing about the bench. The girl’s father lifted his shopping bags out of her way, and Mr Hales stood up at once, though he had been halfway through his letters. Neither made the path any wider.
At the meeting, someone had said the paved space was exposed and would make the bench less pleasant in summer. When I measured the proposed position with the caretaker, the afternoon sun fell directly across it. From there, too, the seat faced the blank wall of the store shed instead of the bus turning into the road. The caretaker pointed out that the new position would leave the path clear. He marked its corners with chalk, and the outline looked smaller than the bench itself.
I took a photograph of the chalk rectangle and, on the way out, another of the old place beneath the tree. On my phone they looked like competing answers: one was a clear route; the other held the patch of shade, the turning bus and Mr Hales’s morning letters. I had thought the choice was between keeping the bench and losing it. At the next meeting, I put both photographs on the table and left the space between them empty.
Explain how the narrator’s view of the proposed move develops, and how the conflicting evidence shapes the narrator’s final judgement.
809 exam-style questions on Oxford AQA IGCSE English Language 5.1 AO1: Reading, covering 5.1.1 R1: Read and understand texts, 5.1.2 R2: Collate and synthesise across sources, 5.1.3 R3: Develop and sustain interpretations, and 5.1.4 R4: Explain and evaluate writers' use of features. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.