A school is comparing a steel noticeboard with a plastic noticeboard for the same outdoor location.
The table shows data for one noticeboard made from each material.
| Stage | Steel noticeboard | Plastic noticeboard |
|---|---|---|
| energy to obtain raw materials / MJ | 300 | 90 |
| energy to manufacture the noticeboard / MJ | 180 | 70 |
| expected lifetime / years | 20 | 5 |
| disposal | recycled | sent to landfill |
In this question, production energy is the total energy used to obtain the raw materials and manufacture the noticeboard.
Calculate the production energy for one noticeboard made from each material.
The energy calculated in (a) can be spread across the expected lifetime. Calculate the annual production-energy value for each noticeboard.
State which material should be selected if the decision is based only on annual production energy. Give a reason using your answers to (b).
Give one environmental advantage of the disposal route shown for the steel noticeboard compared with the disposal route shown for the plastic noticeboard.
Two organisations complete life cycle assessments of the noticeboards but reach different conclusions. Suggest one reason for this difference.
121 exam-style questions on Edexcel GCSE Chemistry 5.1 Obtaining and using metals, covering 5.1.1 The reactivity series of metals, 5.1.2 Displacement reactions as redox reactions, 5.1.3 Extracting metals from ores by reduction, 5.1.4 Biological methods of metal extraction, 5.1.5 Resistance to oxidation and recycling metals, and 5.1.6 Life cycle assessment. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.