Best Buys Exam Questions: GCSE Worked Examples
Best buys exam questions made clear with three GCSE worked examples, method marks, common mistakes and focused practice for stronger exam answers.

A best buys question can look almost too ordinary. Two packet sizes, two prices, perhaps a discount. Yet this familiar shopping problem tests an important mathematical habit: comparing like with like.
The safest way to answer best buys exam questions is to calculate the same unit cost for every option. That might be the cost per item, per gram, per kilogram or per litre. You then compare those figures and write a conclusion.
Imagine a student called Maya working through three questions before her GCSE Maths exam. Her arithmetic is mostly secure, but she sometimes chooses the apparently cheaper price without accounting for quantity. Here is how she turns that instinct into a method that can earn marks.
The best buys method
Use this checklist whenever you compare value for money:
- Identify the quantity and price of each option.
- Choose one common unit for the comparison.
- Divide to find the cost per unit, or scale both options to the same quantity.
- Account for discounts, multi-buy offers and whole packs.
- Compare the final figures.
- State which option is the better buy and support the decision with your calculations.
Both common approaches are valid. You could calculate the cost of one item:
unit cost=total costnumber of items\text{unit cost}=\frac{\text{total cost}}{\text{number of items}}unit cost=number of itemstotal costAlternatively, you could scale both deals to an equal quantity. The important point is fairness. Comparing a packet price with a unit price does not answer the question.
The precise allocation of marks depends on the exam board and question, but marks are commonly available for setting up a suitable calculation, obtaining comparable values and reaching a supported conclusion. You can build the underlying technique with the Maths Genie Best Buy Questions lesson.
Question one: comparing cost per item
Maya begins with a direct comparison.
Exam-style question:
Shop A sells a pack of 444 notebooks for £3.60£3.60£3.60.
Shop B sells a pack of 666 notebooks for £5.10£5.10£5.10.
Which shop offers the better value?
Step one: find Shop A's unit cost
£3.60÷4=£0.90£3.60 \div 4 = £0.90£3.60÷4=£0.90Each notebook costs 90p90\text{p}90p.
Step two: find Shop B's unit cost
£5.10÷6=£0.85£5.10 \div 6 = £0.85£5.10÷6=£0.85Each notebook costs 85p85\text{p}85p.
Step three: compare and conclude
Shop B is the better buy because each notebook costs 85p85\text{p}85p rather than 90p90\text{p}90p.
In an illustrative three-mark structure, Maya might receive one method mark for each correct unit-cost calculation and an accuracy or conclusion mark for selecting Shop B with supporting figures. Writing only “Shop B” risks losing the marks attached to the method.
The wider Best Buy Questions revision page brings the lesson, questions and worked resources together.
Question two: converting different units
The next question is harder because the quantities are expressed in grams and kilograms.
Exam-style question:
Bag A contains 750 g750\text{ g}750 g of rice and costs £2.70£2.70£2.70.
Bag B contains 1.2 kg1.2\text{ kg}1.2 kg of rice and costs £4.08£4.08£4.08.
Which bag is the better buy?
Maya decides to compare the cost per kilogram. She first converts 750 g750\text{ g}750 g into kilograms:
750 g=0.75 kg750\text{ g}=0.75\text{ kg}750 g=0.75 kgFor Bag A:
£2.70÷0.75=£3.60£2.70 \div 0.75 = £3.60£2.70÷0.75=£3.60Bag A costs £3.60£3.60£3.60 per kilogram.
For Bag B:
£4.08÷1.2=£3.40£4.08 \div 1.2 = £3.40£4.08÷1.2=£3.40Bag B costs £3.40£3.40£3.40 per kilogram. Therefore, Bag B is the better buy.
The conversion is part of the reasoning, so Maya writes it down rather than trying to hold every step in her head. In a typical multi-mark question, a correct conversion or equivalent scaling method can contribute to the method marks even if a later arithmetic slip occurs. Exact marking always follows the paper's published mark scheme.
If setting out these comparisons still feels slow, use the Best Buy Questions lesson and Best Buy Questions question bank to practise the same method across varied exam-style problems.
Question three: discounts and whole packs
Maya's final question includes two complications. She must buy enough bottles, and one shop applies a discount.
Exam-style question:
Maya needs at least 181818 bottles.
Shop A sells packs of 666 for £4.50£4.50£4.50 and offers the third pack at half price when three packs are bought.
Shop B sells packs of 444 for £2.68£2.68£2.68 and gives 15%15\%15% off the total when five packs are bought.
Which shop is cheaper for buying enough bottles?
Shop A
Three packs provide exactly:
3×6=183 \times 6=183×6=18The third pack costs:
£4.50÷2=£2.25£4.50 \div 2=£2.25£4.50÷2=£2.25The total is:
£4.50+£4.50+£2.25=£11.25£4.50+£4.50+£2.25=£11.25£4.50+£4.50+£2.25=£11.25Shop B
Four packs would provide only:
4×4=164 \times 4=164×4=16That is not enough, so Maya must buy five packs, giving 202020 bottles. Before the discount, the cost is:
5×£2.68=£13.405 \times £2.68=£13.405×£2.68=£13.40The discount is:
15% of £13.40=0.15×£13.40=£2.0115\% \text{ of } £13.40=0.15 \times £13.40=£2.0115% of £13.40=0.15×£13.40=£2.01The discounted total is:
£13.40−£2.01=£11.39£13.40-£2.01=£11.39£13.40−£2.01=£11.39Shop A is cheaper because £11.25<£11.39£11.25<£11.39£11.25<£11.39. It is cheaper by:
£11.39−£11.25=£0.14£11.39-£11.25=£0.14£11.39−£11.25=£0.14Maya's conclusion includes both totals. That matters because “Shop A” alone does not demonstrate that she handled the pack sizes and discounts correctly.
For more mixed arithmetic problems, the Calculation Problems revision lesson is a useful companion topic.
Common mistakes in the best buys GCSE exam
Choosing the lowest displayed price
The cheapest packet is not necessarily the best value. A smaller packet may cost less overall but more per item. Always compare equal quantities or equal units.
Using different comparison units
Do not calculate pence per gram for one option and pounds per kilogram for another. Convert both answers into the same unit before comparing them.
Ignoring whole packs
You cannot usually buy part of a sealed pack. If 181818 items are needed and packs contain 444, you need 555 packs, not 4.54.54.5 packs.
Applying a percentage discount incorrectly
A discount is subtracted from the original amount. For a 15%15\%15% discount, either calculate 15%15\%15% and subtract it or calculate 85%85\%85% of the original price.
Giving an unsupported answer
Finish with a sentence naming the better buy and quoting the relevant costs. Examiners should not have to infer your decision from scattered calculations.
Exam-style practice
Try these without looking back at the examples.
- A pack of 888 pens costs £3.12£3.12£3.12. A pack of 121212 costs £4.44£4.44£4.44. Which is the better buy?
- A 600 ml600\text{ ml}600 ml bottle costs £1.74£1.74£1.74. A 1.5 litre1.5\text{ litre}1.5 litre bottle costs £4.20£4.20£4.20. Which costs less per litre?
- Packs of 555 cereal bars cost £2.25£2.25£2.25. Packs of 888 cost £3.68£3.68£3.68, but buying two packs gives a 10%10\%10% discount. Find the cheaper way to buy at least 151515 bars.
The answers are the pack of 121212 pens at 37p37\text{p}37p per pen, the 1.5 litre1.5\text{ litre}1.5 litre bottle at £2.80£2.80£2.80 per litre, and two discounted packs of 888 bars for £6.624£6.624£6.624, which would normally be charged as £6.62£6.62£6.62 when rounded to the nearest penny.
You can continue with the printable Best Buy Questions exam booklet, or choose your specification from the GCSE Maths revision hub. The OCR Best Buy revision guide also reinforces the principle of comparing costs in a common unit.
Turn the method into exam marks
Maya improved her answers by slowing down at three moments: choosing a common unit, showing every price calculation and writing a supported conclusion. Knowing that structure is the first step; following it reliably under exam pressure requires focused practice.
Build that habit now with the Maths Genie Best Buy Lessons and Question Bank.



