The blue card
Source: an original fiction extract.
Mara took the blue card from Celia’s lectern and folded it once before sliding it into her blazer pocket. The hall doors had not yet opened, but voices crowded the corridor outside. In five minutes, the public-speaking final would begin. Mara looked towards the empty judges’ table and then at the pocket where the card made a sharp rectangle against the cloth. Last year, Celia had beaten her by a single point.
When the audience entered, Mara remained beside her own lectern, reading the same line of her speech without taking it in. Celia arrived last, breathless and carrying a glass of water. She searched beneath her notes, then crouched to look on the floor. The competition organiser checked his watch. “Your prompt card was placed there this morning,” he said. Celia looked across at Mara, but Mara lowered her eyes. The organiser called for silence, and Celia walked to the centre of the stage without the card.
The card pressed against Mara’s ribs as Celia began. Ten minutes earlier, while testing the microphone, Mara had noticed a sentence printed across its front: A promise can become a cage. It was the opening she had written at midnight and submitted with her draft. She had shown it only to the organiser. Seeing it on Celia’s lectern had felt like finding her own handwriting in somebody else’s notebook. Mara had taken the card before she had decided what she would say about it.
Celia’s first sentences were slow and separated by long pauses. Then she put down her notes. Instead of speaking about promises, she described the evening her family had become lost on a winter walk and how a stranger had guided them home. The audience grew still. By the end, Celia was speaking directly to the back row, and Mara could no longer connect any part of the speech with her own draft. As the applause began, the organiser lifted a folder from the judges’ table. Several blue cards slipped out and scattered across the floor, each with a finalist’s name written on the back.
Mara unfolded the card in her pocket. On the reverse, beneath the crease, was her own name. She turned towards her lectern and lifted the card she had ignored there all morning. It had Celia’s name on it. Before Mara could speak, the head judge announced the scores. Mara had won by a single point.
Celia did not look at the certificate. She looked at the two cards in Mara’s hands. Mara carried them to the judges’ table and explained where each one had been. The head judge placed the unsigned certificate beside the score sheet. “When did you discover the mistake?” she asked.
Mara glanced towards Celia, who was waiting in the suddenly quiet hall. “Not soon enough,” Mara said.
Consider the whole source. Analyse how the writer structures the text so that the reader repeatedly revises their judgement of Mara’s decision to take the card. You could consider the opening focus, the delayed explanation, shifts between Mara and Celia and the ending. Support your explanation with references to the source.
407 exam-style questions on AQA GCSE English Language 5.2 Content, covering 5.2.1 Reading source: literature fiction text, 5.2.2 Focus of the extracts, 5.2.3 Stimulus for students' own writing, and 5.2.4 Scenario sets audience, purpose and form. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.