The numbered specimen
Source: an original fiction extract.
At twenty to three on Wednesday afternoon, Nadiya pushed open the museum's side door with her notebook pressed against her coat. She had come for specimen 18. The volunteer at the desk had told her that the catalogue card needed one exact name, and Nadiya had spent the bus journey writing three possibilities in a column and crossing out two of them. She had twenty minutes before the museum closed.
The store room was colder than the public galleries. Rows of shallow drawers covered one wall, each with a small white number. Nadiya found 18, pulled the handle and felt it catch. She tried again. Somewhere behind her, the volunteer began locking the display cases one by one. The clicks travelled along the corridor. Nadiya glanced at the clock, then at the drawer, and kept both hands on its handle.
The volunteer returned with a key. The drawer opened reluctantly, releasing a smell of dust and metal. Inside lay a grey, curved object on a square of cotton wool. A thin line ran across its surface. Nadiya bent over it. She compared its curve with the drawings in her notebook, then moved the desk lamp closer. The line was not part of any drawing. It continued beneath a faded paper label and disappeared.
While she waited for the volunteer to find the old catalogue, Nadiya lifted the label's corner. Underneath it, someone had written in pencil: “Perhaps not a shell?” Below that were two dates, several initials and another question mark. The handwriting changed from line to line. Nadiya stopped turning the pages of her notebook. She read the small comments instead, following the marks left by people who had examined the same object and left without settling it.
“It has been here longer than I have,” the volunteer said. He placed a thick ledger beside the drawer. “The card was started before the new cases were built.”
Outside, a bell sounded once. The museum would close in ten minutes. Nadiya wrote the name she now believed was right at the top of the card. She wrote it carefully, making the letters as clear as the printed number 18. Then, beneath it, she copied the oldest pencil question and left a line of empty space after it. She closed the drawer, but before she returned the key, she looked once more at the thin line beneath the label.
Read the extract as a whole. Analyse how the writer structures the text to make the reader reconsider what Nadiya is trying to achieve, and how the ending changes the significance of her original goal. Support your response with references to the extract.
407 exam-style questions on AQA GCSE English Language 5.2 Content, covering 5.2.1 Reading source: literature fiction text, 5.2.2 Focus of the extracts, 5.2.3 Stimulus for students' own writing, and 5.2.4 Scenario sets audience, purpose and form. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.