The debate shield
Source: an original fiction extract.
Nadiya noticed the missing name before she noticed her own. The wooden shield displayed twenty-seven winners of the town debate, each engraved on a narrow strip of brass. Her sister’s name should have appeared near the middle, between 2014 and 2016, but another student’s was there instead. At the bottom, a temporary paper label announced that Nadiya Khan and Peter Rowe would compete for this year’s place. She read it twice, as though the order might change.
The final was being held in the council chamber, where every cough rose towards the painted ceiling. Nadiya had expected Peter to speak first, giving her another twenty minutes to prepare. Instead, the chairperson announced that the order had been reversed. Nadiya’s notes were still folded across her knees when her name was called. As she stood, her bag struck the leg of the chair and the cards inside shifted. She had imagined winning would settle something: perhaps her family would stop saying that Laila had ‘her reasons’ for withdrawing from the same competition, or Laila herself would finally admit that she had been frightened.
Crossing the chamber, Nadiya remembered finding Laila’s old cue cards behind a row of cookery books a month earlier. The opening cards were covered with confident handwriting. On the final one, however, a whole paragraph had been crossed out. Beneath it, Laila had written, ‘Eva earned the place. Let her finish.’ Nadiya had taken this as an excuse dressed up as generosity. That morning, she had put the cards in her bag as proof that she understood what had happened.
By the time she reached the microphone, the chamber seemed to have contracted around it. Nadiya began steadily. Her argument concerned responsibility, and she had included a line about people who abandoned difficult tasks and left others to complete them. As she spoke it, she saw an elderly woman in the front row close a red folder and look directly at her. For the first time, the line sounded less powerful than cruel. Nadiya hurried through the conclusion, aware only of the microphone catching each breath and the chairperson’s pen moving across the page.
During the judges’ discussion, the woman with the red folder approached. She introduced herself as Mrs Bell, the teacher who had organised the debate in Laila’s year. Eva had written the winning argument in the qualifying round, she explained, but had missed the presentation because she had been caring for her younger brother. The rules had given Laila the place automatically. Laila had refused to accept it unless Eva was allowed to present her own work in the final. ‘She knew everyone would think she had lost her nerve,’ Mrs Bell said. ‘She did it anyway.’
The chairperson returned with the result, but Nadiya was looking at her sister’s cue cards. Peter’s name was announced and the room applauded. Outside the chamber, Nadiya found a message from Laila: I’m by the front steps if you want a lift. Laila was waiting beneath the shield when Nadiya came downstairs. Nadiya held out the cards. ‘I found these,’ she said. Then, before Laila could answer, she added, ‘I think I read them in the wrong order.’
Consider the whole source. Analyse how the writer structures the text to develop Nadiya’s changing understanding of her sister’s withdrawal from the debate. You could consider the opening focus, shifts in time, changes in pace and the ending. Support your explanation with references to the source.
407 exam-style questions on AQA GCSE English Language 5.2 Content, covering 5.2.1 Reading source: literature fiction text, 5.2.2 Focus of the extracts, 5.2.3 Stimulus for students' own writing, and 5.2.4 Scenario sets audience, purpose and form. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.