A conservation laboratory examines water collected while cleaning a stone statue. The water could contain carbonate ions, sulfate ions or both. Dilute hydrochloric acid is mixed with the water and the gas released is passed into limewater, which becomes milky. Once gas production has stopped, barium chloride solution is mixed with the acidified water. No precipitate is seen.
Which conclusion is correct?
The ions cannot be distinguished; both carbonate and sulfate turn limewater milky after reacting with dilute acid.
Both carbonate and sulfate ions were detected; acid removed sulfate, so no precipitate formed in the barium test.
Only carbonate ions were detected; acid removed carbonate, so no precipitate means sulfate was not detected.
Neither ion was detected; a white precipitate with barium chloride is needed to identify either ion.
74 exam-style questions on Edexcel GCSE Chemistry 10.1 Qualitative analysis: tests for ions, covering 10.1.1 Principles of ion tests and flame tests, 10.1.2 Tests for cations and for ammonia, 10.1.3 Tests for anions, 10.1.4 Identification of ions in unknown salts, and 10.1.5 Instrumental methods of analysis. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.