A water-treatment laboratory is deciding which procedure to use to test a process solution for sulfate ions. Two technicians test fresh portions of the same solution.
| Procedure | Method and observations |
|---|---|
| A | Barium chloride solution is added directly. A white precipitate forms. |
| B | Dilute hydrochloric acid is added until no more effervescence occurs. The gas produced turns limewater milky. Barium chloride solution is then added. No precipitate forms. |
The laboratory manager states that sulfate ions are present because procedure A produced a white precipitate.
Evaluate the manager's statement and the two procedures.
74 exam-style questions on Edexcel GCSE Chemistry 10.1 Qualitative analysis: tests for ions, covering 10.1.1 Principles of ion tests and flame tests, 10.1.2 Tests for cations and for ammonia, 10.1.3 Tests for anions, 10.1.4 Identification of ions in unknown salts, and 10.1.5 Instrumental methods of analysis. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.