Disproof by Counterexample in A-Level Maths
Disproof by counterexample A-Level Maths explained with a clear method, worked examples, common mistakes and exam-style practice questions.

A statement can look convincing for a surprisingly long time. You test it with 111, then 222, perhaps 333, and everything works. It begins to feel true. But mathematics does not ask whether a universal statement works sometimes. It asks whether it works every time.
That is the central idea behind disproof by counterexample in A-Level Maths: to disprove a claim that says something is always true, you need only find one valid case where it is false.
Imagine a sixth-form student facing the claim, “The sum of two prime numbers is always even.” Several quick tests appear to support it. Then they try 2+3=52+3=52+3=5. One small exception settles the question completely. The skill is not doing lots of calculations. It is choosing one decisive example and explaining why it works.
The method at a glance
When asked to disprove a statement by counterexample:
- identify exactly what the statement claims;
- note the permitted domain, such as integers or real numbers;
- look for an edge case or a value with unusual properties;
- check that your example satisfies every condition;
- show clearly that its result contradicts the conclusion;
- state that the original claim is therefore false.
The logical form is simple. To disprove a claim such as
For every x∈S, P(x) is true,\text{For every }x\in S,\ P(x)\text{ is true},For every x∈S, P(x) is true,find one value a∈Sa\in Sa∈S for which P(a)P(a)P(a) is false.
A lone exception interrupts a crowd claiming everyone agrees
What a counterexample actually proves
A counterexample disproves a universal statement, meaning one that applies to every object in a stated set. Typical warning words are “all”, “every”, “always” and “for any”.
Suppose the claim is:
For every integer nnn, the expression n2+n+1n^2+n+1n2+n+1 is prime.
You do not need to check every integer. Indeed, checking every integer would be impossible. You need one integer for which the expression is not prime.
A counterexample does not explain every feature of the statement, and it does not create a proof of a different claim. It has one precise job: it demonstrates that the original universal claim cannot be true.
The reverse situation matters too. Testing many successful cases does not prove a universal statement. A thousand examples can build confidence, but the next case might fail. This distinction between evidence and proof sits at the heart of A-Level mathematical reasoning.
A reliable step-by-step approach
The student in our example stops trying random numbers and starts reading each claim as a set of instructions.
Read the quantifier
First, find the word controlling the claim. If it says “all positive integers”, your counterexample must be a positive integer. If it concerns non-zero real numbers, using 000 is invalid, however convenient it might appear.
Identify what must fail
Separate the conditions from the conclusion. In the statement
If an integer is squared, the result is greater than the original integer,
an acceptable example must be an integer, but its square must not be greater than that integer.
Test strategic values
Useful candidates often include:
- 000, 111 and −1-1−1;
- negative values;
- equal values where two variables are allowed;
- fractions between 000 and 111;
- boundary values;
- even and odd integers;
- the smallest object allowed by the domain.
These values expose assumptions hidden inside statements. For instance, people often assume squaring makes a number larger, forgetting what happens between 000 and 111.
Write a complete conclusion
A bare number may suggest the answer, but an exam response should connect the example to the claim. Substitute the value, show the contradiction, and conclude explicitly that the statement is false.
Once this method feels manageable, use the Maths Genie A-Level Maths lessons and Question Bank to practise choosing decisive examples rather than testing values at random.
Disproof by counterexample worked examples
Worked example: an algebraic claim
Disprove the statement:
For every real number xxx, x2≥xx^2\geq xx2≥x.
Step 1: Check the domain. Any real value of xxx is permitted.
Step 2: Look for a vulnerable region. For values between 000 and 111, squaring makes a positive number smaller.
Step 3: Choose and test one value. Let x=12x=\frac{1}{2}x=21. Then
x2=(12)2=14.x^2=\left(\frac{1}{2}\right)^2=\frac{1}{4}.x2=(21)2=41.But
14<12.\frac{1}{4}<\frac{1}{2}.41<21.Therefore x2≱xx^2\not\geq xx2≥x when x=12x=\frac{1}{2}x=21, so the statement is false.
Notice what made this efficient. The student did not produce a list of decimal trials. They recognised the interval where the claim would fail and selected one exact value.
Worked example: an integer claim
Disprove the statement:
For every integer nnn, n2+n+1n^2+n+1n2+n+1 is prime.
Try n=4n=4n=4:
n2+n+1=42+4+1=21.n^2+n+1=4^2+4+1=21.n2+n+1=42+4+1=21.Since
21=3×7,21=3\times 7,21=3×7,212121 is composite, not prime. Therefore n=4n=4n=4 is a counterexample and the statement is false.
Here, writing the factorisation matters. Merely giving 212121 expects the examiner to supply the reason it contradicts “prime”. A complete solution makes that reason visible.
Worked example: a statement about odd numbers
Disprove the statement:
The product of two odd integers is always greater than each integer.
Choose the odd integers 111 and 333. Their product is
1×3=3.1\times 3=3.1×3=3.The product is equal to 333, so it is not greater than each of the original integers. Therefore the claim is false.
This example shows why simple values are powerful. A counterexample does not earn extra credit for being complicated.
How to answer disproof by counterexample exam questions
A strong exam response can often be written in three lines:
- state a permitted value;
- substitute it and calculate;
- explain the contradiction and conclude that the statement is false.
A useful template is:
Let x=…x=\ldotsx=…, which satisfies the stated conditions. Then …\ldots…. This contradicts the claim that …\ldots…, so the statement is false.
You are not normally being asked to prove why your chosen case is the only counterexample. There may be infinitely many. One valid exception is sufficient.
Keep the domain in view throughout. If the question is about natural numbers, a negative integer will not work. If the statement concerns distinct numbers, choosing equal values breaks a condition before you even test the conclusion.
Exam-style practice
Try these before reading any notes again. For each one, aim to give a single example, a calculation and a conclusion.
Practice question A
Disprove the statement:
For every positive integer nnn, n2+n+11n^2+n+11n2+n+11 is prime.
A strategic approach is to test values connected to the constant term rather than moving mechanically through every small integer.
Practice question B
Disprove the statement:
If aaa and bbb are real numbers and a2=b2a^2=b^2a2=b2, then a=ba=ba=b.
Think about what squaring does to the sign of a number.
Practice question C
Disprove the statement:
The sum of two irrational numbers is irrational.
Your two chosen values must each be irrational, while their sum must contradict the conclusion.
Answers
For A, take n=11n=11n=11:
112+11+11=143=11×13,11^2+11+11=143=11\times 13,112+11+11=143=11×13,which is composite. The statement is false.
For B, take a=1a=1a=1 and b=−1b=-1b=−1. Then
a2=1=b2,a^2=1=b^2,a2=1=b2,but a≠ba\neq ba=b. The statement is false.
For C, choose 2\sqrt{2}2 and −2-\sqrt{2}−2. Both are irrational, but
2+(−2)=0,\sqrt{2}+(-\sqrt{2})=0,2+(−2)=0,which is rational. The statement is false.
Common mistakes to avoid
Giving supporting examples
If the claim says all prime numbers are odd, choosing 333, 555 and 777 supports the claim but does not settle it. A disproof must make the conclusion fail. In this case, 222 is the decisive counterexample.
Ignoring the domain
A value outside the stated set cannot be a counterexample. For a claim about positive integers, neither 000 nor −1-1−1 is admissible.
Breaking a condition
If a claim begins “For distinct non-zero real numbers...”, your example must use values that are both distinct and non-zero. Check every adjective in the question.
Giving no explanation
A value without substitution or comparison leaves the logic unfinished. Show exactly where the claim fails.
Trying to prove the opposite
Disproof is usually shorter. You do not have to establish a new universal theorem. One valid counterexample is enough.
Turn the method into marks
The student’s progress does not come from memorising a lucky list of counterexamples. It comes from repeating the same disciplined routine: identify the domain, target the conclusion, test an edge case and write the contradiction clearly. Knowing that routine is the first step; recognising the right example under exam pressure requires practice.
Use the Maths Genie A-Level lessons and Question Bank to work through disproof by counterexample exam questions, check the reasoning, and make this short proof technique dependable. Start the matching lesson and practise the Question Bank now.



