Plant beyond the planting day
Text One: The row that looked finished
An original account by a teenager helping with a neighbourhood tree-planting project.
Our target was twenty-five trees. Once we had written that number on the project page, reaching it began to seem like the whole purpose. The strip of grass beside the community hall looked empty, so we treated it as twenty-five available spaces. I chose trees from small catalogue photographs, paying more attention to blossom and price than to their eventual height, spread or growing conditions.
Questions arrived after the order. A resident wondered whether branches would eventually block light from the hall windows. Another pointed out that people crossed the grass to reach the bus stop. We had received encouragement from the hall caretaker, but we had not confirmed permission with the organisation responsible for the land or arranged the proper checks for anything beneath it. Planting in one section had to be postponed.
The remaining trees went in during a busy Saturday morning. Volunteers wanted to help, photographs were being taken and our progress board displayed the rising total. Near the end, we placed several trees closer together than planned rather than admit that the site could not sensibly hold the number we had promised. We had also spent most of our money on additional trees, leaving little for mulch, watering equipment or replacement ties.
For a few weeks, the row looked complete. Then the weather became dry. People who lived nearby assumed the hall was watering; the hall staff assumed our group was returning. Several trees developed drooping leaves before anybody discovered that the soil around them was dry. One support tie became tight as its tree moved, while a tree selected for its flowers showed little growth in a heavily shaded corner.
At first, we blamed disappointing trees and unreliable volunteers. Neither explanation addressed the plan. We had not matched each tree to a surveyed position, agreed how care would be organised or kept a clear record of what had been planted where. Our target counted trees entering the ground, not trees becoming established there.
For the next stage, we started with the place rather than the catalogue. The landowner confirmed which areas could be used, and the appropriate checks were completed before digging. We recorded sunny, shaded, exposed and damp areas, protected access across the site and asked nearby residents how they used the space.
We then chose a smaller number of trees for specific purposes and conditions. Funds were reserved for aftercare, and each tree was recorded by its location, type and planting date. A project coordinator arranged watering according to the weather and soil, while volunteers reported damaged guards, tight ties or signs of poor growth.
The second planting produced a less impressive total for our noticeboard. It created a much better chance that the trees would still be improving the neighbourhood long after the photographs had been forgotten.
Text Two: Help a tree belong to its place
An original article by the coordinator of a youth environmental network.
A successful tree project does not simply move young trees into holes. Its purpose may be to provide future shade, improve a shared space, support wildlife or create a more pleasant boundary. Those aims should guide decisions about position, species and number. A large planting total is of little value if the site cannot support the trees or the group cannot care for them.
Begin by establishing who controls the land and what permission is required. Survey how the place is already used, including paths, entrances, seating, windows and open areas needed for activities. The responsible organisation should arrange checks for underground services and any other restrictions before digging begins.
Growing conditions vary across even a small site. Record light, exposure, drainage, available soil and space. Select trees suited to those conditions, considering their mature height and spread rather than judging them only as young plants. A mixture of suitable types may also be more resilient than relying entirely on one type. Local knowledge can reveal flooding, heavy foot traffic or valued views that a brief visit misses.
Consultation should lead to practical decisions, not merely collect general approval. Ask residents and users what they value about the space, where additional shade would help and which routes must remain clear. Not every request can be followed, but explaining the project’s aims and constraints can prevent avoidable conflict.
Plan the planting day around safe, careful work rather than the largest possible crowd or fastest possible total. Provide appropriate tools, instructions and supervision. Order only the number of trees that can be positioned properly, and protect part of the budget for mulch, guards, watering equipment and later maintenance.
Aftercare must be designed before planting. Watering should respond to weather and soil conditions instead of following an unchanging routine. Keep the area around each young tree from becoming overwhelmed by competing growth, place mulch appropriately without piling it against the trunk, and inspect guards, stakes and ties as the tree develops. Records of location, planting date and observations help a group notice patterns rather than rely on memory.
Review losses honestly. A tree may fail because the position, planting, weather, damage or aftercare was unsuitable. Investigate the likely cause before putting an identical replacement in the same place. Measure progress through survival, healthy establishment and benefits to the site, not through the number planted on one morning.
Use ideas from both texts to answer this question.
Write a contribution to a youth environmental-project website with the title “Plant beyond the planting day”. Advise readers planning and maintaining a neighbourhood tree-planting project.
You should include:
Think carefully about your purpose and the audience for whom you are writing.
212 exam-style questions on Edexcel B IGCSE English Language 2.4.2 Directed writing task based on source texts. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.