An archive with people in it
Text One: The poem I thought had disappeared
An original account by a former pupil responding to a fictional school’s digitisation proposal.
The school wrote to say that it planned to put old magazines online. I was pleased at first. My father had written for an earlier issue, and our paper copy had lost its cover before I was old enough to read it. An online collection might finally let us find his work without arranging a journey to the school office.
Then I remembered my own poem. At fourteen, I had described an argument at home in language I now found embarrassingly certain. The magazine had circulated around the school and a few families. That audience had felt enormous then. I had not imagined the words appearing beside my name whenever someone searched for it years later.
I do not want the school to pretend that its pupils always wrote calmly or lived uncomplicated lives. Removing every awkward page would turn the archive into a prospectus composed after the event. My poem also reminds me that somebody once took my writing seriously enough to print it. That part of the memory matters.
What troubles me is the assumption that scanning a page simply preserves the original arrangement. A copy kept in a cupboard and a page searchable far beyond the school do not create the same kind of audience. I would like to know what will be searchable, how concerns can be raised and what choices the school is willing to consider before publishing.
There are limits to any easy answer. Some former pupils cannot be contacted. A page can contain several people's work, and removing one contribution may change the record around another. I would not expect staff to resolve all that by following whichever request arrives first.
I still hope to read my father's article online. I also hope the announcement will become a conversation about access, context and the people attached to the pages. The archive should show that the school remembers more than the fact that it owns a scanner.
Text Two: Access is a design decision
An original article by an archivist discussing the fictional school magazine collection.
Digitisation can widen access to material which is fragile, distant or seldom opened. Former pupils may recover work their families no longer possess, and readers can discover changes in school life which a selected anniversary display would overlook. Keeping everything inaccessible is not a neutral way to protect history; it can also determine who is able to encounter it.
However, preservation and unrestricted online publication are different decisions. A scan can be retained without every element being made equally searchable or available in the same form. What arrangements are appropriate depends on the collection, the people involved and the requirements which apply. Those matters should be checked through the proper channels, rather than answered by a slogan about either openness or privacy.
An archive should not quietly rewrite the past to make its institution look better. At the same time, leaving material unchanged does not remove the responsibility to explain it. A short contextual note can distinguish a youthful contribution or an old editorial practice from a current statement by the school. Context has limits too: a note does not automatically answer every concern raised by a named person.
Set out a process before publication. Explain what is proposed, how concerns can be submitted, who will consider them and how decisions will be recorded. Consider different levels or methods of access where appropriate. Do not imply that one universal arrangement will satisfy every page, or promise an individual outcome before understanding its effects on the wider record.
This work requires time and resources. A smaller, carefully considered release may be more responsible than a complete launch followed by hurried decisions under pressure. Review the process as experience develops. Success is not simply the number of pages online; it includes whether access has improved, the record remains intelligible and people understand how concerns about it will be addressed.
Use ideas from both texts to answer this question.
Write a letter to the headteacher of the school described in the texts recommending how its old magazines should be digitised and made available.
You should include:
Think carefully about your purpose and the audience for whom you are writing.
212 exam-style questions on Edexcel B IGCSE English Language 2.4.2 Directed writing task based on source texts. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.