Ten minutes that mattered
Text One: The week the bell moved
An original account by a student whose school tested a longer morning break.
Our morning break usually lasted fifteen minutes. By the time I had put away my books, reached the canteen and joined the queue, the warning bell was already close. I often returned to lessons carrying food I had not finished and feeling as though the break had been another task to complete quickly.
For one week, the school added ten minutes to morning break. The difference was most noticeable in the canteen. The queue still formed, but there was time to sit down afterwards. Other students used the extra minutes to visit the library, speak to a teacher or simply talk without watching the clock.
The lesson after break felt calmer to me. Most of us were seated before the teacher began, instead of arriving in a final rush. However, this was not true every day. On Tuesday, several students did not hear the warning bell from the far end of the field and came back late.
The longer break also created new difficulties. More students stayed outside, so the area near the doors became crowded when the weather changed. Ten minutes had been taken from lunchtime to keep the end of the school day unchanged. Some students preferred the longer morning break, but others valued having more time at lunch for clubs and activities.
At the end of the week, we completed a short questionnaire. I supported keeping the longer break, although I suggested a louder warning bell and a separate entrance for students returning from the field. The trial did not prove that one timetable would suit everyone. It did give us something more useful than guesses to discuss.
Text Two: Change the routine carefully
An original article by a writer considering changes to the school day.
A timetable can appear to be a simple list of lessons and breaks, but changing one part affects the rest. Before extending a break, a school should be clear about the problem it is trying to solve. Students may need enough time to eat, move between buildings or prepare for the next lesson. A longer break may help, but it should not be treated as the only possible answer.
Different members of the school community may experience the same break differently. A student who buys food may spend much of it in a queue, while another student may use the time for a club or to receive help from a teacher. Staff may also need to consider supervision, crowded areas and whether students can hear the signal to return.
A short trial allows a school to examine what actually happens. It could record whether students return to lessons on time, ask which facilities become crowded and collect views from students and staff. Questions should be specific. Asking whether people enjoyed a longer break is less useful than asking what they were able to do, what became more difficult and which timetable they would prefer.
The school should also explain where the extra time will come from. Reducing lunch, shortening another break or extending the day will affect people in different ways. A decision is more likely to be accepted when these consequences are discussed openly.
Consultation does not mean that every person will receive their preferred timetable. It means that the decision is informed by a range of experiences. After a trial, the school may keep the change, adjust it or return to the original arrangement. Each outcome can be reasonable if the evidence has been considered carefully.
Use ideas from both texts to answer this question.
Write an article for your school magazine with the title “Ten minutes that mattered”. Discuss whether a longer morning break would improve the school day.
You should include:
Think carefully about your purpose and the audience for whom you are writing.
212 exam-style questions on Edexcel B IGCSE English Language 2.4.2 Directed writing task based on source texts. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.