Trust is part of the story
Text One: The headline that went too far
An original account by a student reporter for a school news website.
At lunchtime, I found members of the junior orchestra standing in a corridor with their instrument cases around them. One player said, “We’ve been thrown out again.” I photographed the cases and began writing immediately. My headline was: “Orchestra thrown out of rehearsal room.” The story felt urgent, and I wanted our website to publish it first.
I had seen the corridor, but I had not seen anyone being thrown out. I sent the facilities coordinator a message ten minutes before our deadline. When no answer arrived, I treated that silence as confirmation and published the article. I also named the player I had quoted. She had known I wrote for the website, but I had never explained that I intended to use her name or her exact words.
The coordinator’s reply arrived shortly afterwards. Water had started leaking through the rehearsal-room ceiling that morning, so the room had been closed for inspection. An alternative hall had been offered. That information did not settle everything. The orchestra leader told me that the message about the hall had arrived after the rehearsal began and that the space had nowhere secure for larger instruments. The group had a genuine complaint, but it was not the one my headline claimed.
At first, I quietly replaced “thrown out” with “moved”. By then, readers had shared an image of the original page, and comments were arguing about which version was true. Our editor said that changing a published claim without acknowledgement would create another problem. I added a notice at the top explaining what had been altered and why. I removed the player’s name at her request, then rewrote the article so that it separated the confirmed closure from the disagreement about the alternative room.
The corrected report was less dramatic, but it was more useful. It showed that accuracy is not achieved by choosing one side. It comes from making clear what you witnessed, what other people told you and what you were able to confirm.
Text Two: Reporting without borrowing certainty
An original article by an editor of community news.
A reporter’s first impression may provide a promising lead, but it is not yet a complete account. Begin by separating observation from explanation. You may have seen a cancelled activity or an angry crowd; you may not yet know why it happened or who made the decision. Record dates, retain notes and check whether documents or additional witnesses support important claims.
People or organisations facing criticism should normally have a fair opportunity to respond. Contact them early, state the claim clearly and allow a reasonable time for an answer. If no response arrives, report that fact rather than inventing a motive. Fairness does not mean pretending that every claim has equal evidence behind it. A reply may supply relevant context, while a well-supported criticism may remain valid.
Be equally clear with the people who give you information. Explain where the report will appear and discuss whether they will be named. Quote their words accurately and preserve the context in which they were spoken. Private details should not be included merely because they make a report more dramatic. Consider whether the information helps readers understand an issue of genuine concern.
Headlines, captions and opening sentences deserve particular care because some readers will see nothing else. They must not state a stronger conclusion than the report supports. Distinguish between a confirmed event, a person’s allegation and the writer’s opinion. Words such as “claims” do not excuse publishing an accusation without checking it.
Mistakes should be corrected promptly and where readers are likely to notice the correction. A significant change should include a brief explanation rather than being hidden by silently replacing the original wording. Acknowledging uncertainty or error may feel uncomfortable, but openness gives readers a reason to trust future reporting. Responsible journalism is not slow because it lacks confidence; it takes enough care to ensure that confidence is earned.
Use ideas from both texts to answer the question.
Write a contribution to a student project website with the title “Trust is part of the story”. Advise students who are preparing reports about issues in their school or community.
You should include:
Think carefully about your purpose and the audience for whom you are writing.
212 exam-style questions on Edexcel B IGCSE English Language 2.4.2 Directed writing task based on source texts. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.