Growing together, deciding together
Text One: The label on the tomatoes
An original account by a teenager involved in a communal courtyard garden.
The disagreement began with six tomatoes in a paper bag. I had picked them from a planter in our courtyard, intending to use them for sandwiches at the residents’ meeting. Lena stopped me on the stairs. She and her granddaughter had raised those plants and had been saving the tomatoes for a family meal.
I pointed towards the sign at the gate: “Community Garden”. Lena replied that a shared name did not make every plant available to everyone. We were both certain that the meaning was obvious, but we had understood it differently.
When the garden was first proposed, nearly everyone supported it. Unfortunately, agreement about having a garden had hidden disagreement about what it should be. I imagined beds full of vegetables for communal meals. One neighbour wanted flowers beside the bench. A family hoped for a small plot their children could manage, while another resident was mainly concerned that paths should remain clear. We had discussed enthusiasm without discussing ownership, access or responsibility.
At the next meeting, we resisted turning the missing tomatoes into a trial with one winner. Instead, we listed the decisions we had failed to make. Which beds were communal? Could anyone pick from them? Did caring for a plant give someone a greater claim to its produce? Who would complete regular tasks when other commitments intervened?
The plan we eventually agreed did not make every part of the courtyard the same. One large bed would supply produce for shared meals. Several smaller plots could be allocated to individuals or families. Flowers would grow near the seating area, and the central route would remain unobstructed. Labels would state whether people could pick freely, should ask first or should leave a plant for its named grower.
Responsibilities were shared just as carefully. Some residents chose regular watering times, while others offered occasional help, kept the noticeboard up to date or recorded decisions. Anyone unable to complete a promised task was expected to arrange a swap rather than remain silent. I did not get the whole bed of chilli plants I had imagined, but I did get a marked section and an equal voice in the discussion.
The garden now looks less like one person’s perfect plan and more like a collection of negotiated choices. Sharing has not removed every boundary. It has made those boundaries visible and given us a way to question them.
Text Two: Shared soil needs shared rules
An original article by a coordinator of communal growing spaces.
A garden can be green, productive and deeply unfair. Plants may be thriving while a few people make every decision, complete most of the work or take more than their share of the produce. Successful communal growing therefore depends as much on clear agreements as it does on practical gardening.
Begin by discovering how people hope to use the space. Some may prioritise food, flowers, seating, children’s activities or quiet surroundings. These wishes do not automatically fit together, but neither should the loudest voice or the first person to arrive decide everything. A meeting is useful, although written comments and conversations with people who could not attend may reveal needs that would otherwise be missed.
Decide which choices affect everyone and which can be left to individuals. Routes through the garden, the position of shared beds and the use of common produce require collective agreement. A person using an allocated plot can usually make more personal choices within its boundaries. Record the decisions and the reasons for them so that new members do not have to guess how the system works.
The words “help yourself” are not always helpful. They might refer to one bed, a limited amount or produce set aside for a particular event. Labels should make clear what may be picked, by whom and for what purpose. The same principle applies to equipment and growing areas: unclear generosity can quickly become conflict.
Fair contribution does not mean assigning identical physical tasks to everybody. People have different amounts of time, strength, experience and confidence. Watering, making signs, keeping records, gathering opinions and organising rotas can all support the space. Young people should be trusted with meaningful responsibilities and included in decisions, rather than invited only when heavy work is required.
When an agreement is broken, check whether it was understood before assuming selfishness. Discuss the effect of what happened, refer to the recorded decision and agree how any harm can be repaired. Rules should also have review dates. Circumstances and membership change, but revisions must be made openly rather than through private exceptions for favoured individuals.
The strongest communal gardens do not eliminate differences. They provide a fair process for living with them. Their real harvest is not only what grows in the beds, but also the trust that allows people to keep using the space together.
Use ideas from both texts to answer this question.
Write an article for a youth magazine with the title “Growing together, deciding together”. Show readers how young people can help communal growing spaces remain fair, welcoming and useful when people want different things from them.
You should include:
Think carefully about your purpose and the audience for whom you are writing.
212 exam-style questions on Edexcel B IGCSE English Language 2.4.2 Directed writing task based on source texts. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.