A garden built on more than prizes
Text One: The bed we did not win
An original account by a student involved in a fictional school garden project.
When the school garden opened, I treated it as a competition. Each form was given a raised bed, and the launch poster promised a trophy for the group producing the heaviest harvest. I pictured one exciting afternoon of planting followed by a table covered in vegetables. I did not picture weeks of carrying water, checking labels and deciding what to do when our first plan failed.
Our bed was marked with a large sign saying that it belonged to our form. The sign made us proud, but it also caused confusion. One lunchtime, a younger student noticed that the soil looked dry but walked away because she thought she was not allowed to touch another form's plot. On another day, two groups watered the same bed because neither knew that the other had already done it. During the half-term break, the site manager cared for every plot, although his work was not mentioned when the project was celebrated.
The original gardening club met after school. Several students who travelled home by bus could attend the planning meetings at lunchtime but not the practical sessions. A lunchtime rota was introduced later, which allowed more people to help. However, the rota listed names without stating the jobs to be done. Some students arrived together to take photographs while less noticeable work, such as cleaning tools and updating labels, was repeatedly left to the same two people.
Our first planting did not develop as we expected. We quietly replaced it and photographed only the new plants because we wanted our final display to look successful. Another form recorded an empty section of its bed and explained the decisions it made afterwards. At first, I thought its display looked like an admission of failure. In fact, visitors asked that group more questions because they could see how its plan had changed.
Near the end of term, we disagreed about the garden's purpose. Some students wanted every bed to produce food for a cookery lesson. Others had planted flowers to make an unattractive part of the grounds more welcoming. A third group valued the garden as a calm place to work with friends. Nobody had decided which of these aims mattered most, or who could make that decision.
There was also no agreement about what should happen to the produce. Suggestions included using it in lessons, sharing it among the students who had worked in the garden and contributing it to a school event. The argument began only after everything had been gathered, when there was little time for a considered decision.
Our form did not win the trophy. Its harvest was lighter than that of a bed in a different position which had been planted for a different purpose. I no longer think that one measurement can identify the group which gained most from the project. Next year, the school should keep the enthusiasm of the launch while giving equal attention to the planning, maintenance and honest record of what happens between planting and celebration.
Text Two: Growing a project that can last
An original contribution by the coordinator of the fictional school grounds.
Before extending a school garden, agree what it is intended to achieve. Producing food, improving the appearance of the grounds, providing practical learning and creating a shared social space are all possible aims. They may lead to different choices, so the school should decide its priorities rather than assuming that every bed must produce the same result.
A shared garden needs stewardship, not isolated ownership. Groups can take responsibility for particular areas, but signs and instructions should explain when other members of the school may help. A schedule should identify specific tasks as well as names. It should include arrangements for absences and school holidays, when pupils may be unable to provide regular care.
Participation should not depend entirely on staying after school. Planning, recording, tool care and practical work can take place at different times, allowing students with different commitments to make genuine contributions. Adult assistance may sometimes be essential. It should be planned and acknowledged rather than concealed to preserve the appearance of a wholly pupil-run project.
Decisions about the use of flowers, produce and shared spaces should be made before they become urgent. Students can contribute proposals, while the school identifies who has final responsibility for choices involving its grounds and resources. Publishing these decisions will reduce disputes and help each group understand how its work contributes to the whole project.
Records should reveal development rather than advertise only the best moment. A brief log can show the date, the task completed, the people involved and the reason for any change of plan. Photographs taken from consistent positions can complement that account. Replacing something which did not work is not dishonest; omitting the replacement creates a misleading story.
Final displays should be connected to the agreed aims. The weight of a harvest may be useful for a bed intended to produce food, but it says little about a space created for flowers, practical learning or quiet activity. Beds in different positions may also face different conditions. A single league table therefore risks rewarding circumstances or choices which were never shared by every group.
Celebrate routine and less visible contributions alongside final results. Students, staff and other helpers should be able to explain what they did, what changed and what they would do differently. A garden becomes sustainable when responsibility survives beyond the excitement of its opening day.
Use ideas from both texts to answer this question.
Write a letter to the headteacher setting out a plan for continuing the school garden project next year.
You should include:
Think carefully about your purpose and the audience for whom you are writing.
212 exam-style questions on Edexcel B IGCSE English Language 2.4.2 Directed writing task based on source texts. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.