Text One: More than one watering rule
An original account by a teenager caring for plants at a community garden.
During the school holiday, I agreed to look after six containers outside our community centre. The garden coordinator showed me the tap and pointed out that some pots stood beneath an overhanging roof while others were exposed to rain. I wrote this down, but I still wanted a simpler instruction. “How much water?” seemed like a question which ought to have one numerical answer.
I posted a photograph in a local gardening group. Replies arrived quickly. One person recommended a full watering can every evening; another insisted that the plants should be left alone for a week. The briefest answer received the most signs of approval, so I followed it. Two evenings later, water remained in the tray beneath one container while the soil in a smaller pot was already dry and pulling away from its edge. Repeating the same action had not produced the same result.
Mara, who had worked in the garden for several years, did not replace the online rule with a rule of her own. She asked which containers had received rain, which felt lighter when I carefully lifted them and what changes I had noticed. She explained that the roof, the size of each pot and the recent weather all affected what I was seeing. Her answer initially felt less useful because it required me to make a judgement. In fact, her questions gave me something I could apply the next day.
This did not prove that advice from a distance was worthless. One online contributor had asked whether every container had an open drainage hole. That question led us to discover that a fallen label was blocking one of them. The helpful difference was not simply between an experienced gardener and an unknown person online. It was between advice which pretended not to need any context and advice which helped us inspect the context properly.
At the end of the week, a younger volunteer asked me how much to water the containers. I nearly repeated Mara’s questions as if they were a new script. Instead, I showed him the sheltered and exposed pots, explained what had happened and asked what he noticed. I could share what I had learned without claiming that one week had made me an expert. Good advice, I realised, should leave the next person better able to judge, not merely better trained to obey.
Text Two: A confident answer is not always a useful one
An original article about giving and receiving everyday advice.
Advice often reaches us in its most certain form. A short instruction is easy to remember and share, while an explanation full of conditions can appear hesitant. Popularity may show that a suggestion sounds attractive or has helped some people. It does not establish that the suggestion fits the person asking.
Apparently conflicting recommendations may begin from different assumptions. Two advisers might imagine different aims, resources or levels of experience. Before deciding that one must be foolish, ask what problem each person thinks is being solved. A suggestion can be sensible in one set of circumstances and unsuitable in another.
Useful advisers make their reasoning visible. They ask relevant questions, explain why a detail matters and acknowledge the limits of their experience. Relevant knowledge deserves attention, but impressive language alone is not evidence. The person receiving advice should be able to distinguish between a reasoned recommendation and an unexplained command.
For a low-risk decision, a small and reversible trial may provide useful information. Change one thing, notice what happens and be willing to stop. This is not a suitable approach to every problem. If a decision could seriously affect health, safety or a large amount of money, experimenting alone is unwise. A trusted adult or an appropriately qualified person should be involved.
Receiving advice does not require either automatic obedience or automatic suspicion. State your aim, mention important constraints and ask follow-up questions. If new evidence changes your judgement, changing your mind is a strength rather than an embarrassment. The best advice does more than announce an answer: it helps someone understand the decision they are making.
Use ideas from both texts to answer this question.
Write an article for a youth magazine with the title “The best advice asks questions”. Discuss how readers can judge and use advice without mistaking certainty for usefulness or treating disagreement as a reason to ignore help.
You should include:
Think carefully about your purpose and the audience for whom you are writing.
212 exam-style questions on Edexcel B IGCSE English Language 2.4.2 Directed writing task based on source texts. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.