A welcome is not a timetable
Text One: The afternoon I had already planned
An original account by a student hosting a visiting student for a school exchange.
Before Lina arrived, I prepared an itinerary for every hour of her first weekend. I wanted her to see that we had made an effort, so I included a market, a sports match, a family meal and a tour of the town. I even printed the timetable in colour. There was no empty space on it because empty space looked like poor organisation.
At first, Lina thanked me for the plans. On Saturday morning, however, she asked whether we could return home after the market. She wanted to speak to her family and finish some work she had brought with her. I told her she would regret missing the match because it was an important part of the visit. She came with us, but she said very little.
That evening, my mother asked whether I had ever shown Lina the timetable before she arrived. I had not. I had thought a guest should not have to make decisions. In reality, I had given her a list of decisions which I had already made on her behalf.
The next morning, I asked which plans she would like to keep. Lina chose a short walk and the family meal. She also asked for some time alone. This did not mean that she disliked us or that the exchange was failing. Travelling, meeting unfamiliar people and speaking another language for much of the day required more energy than I had considered.
At school, I had sometimes answered questions for her because I could respond quickly. When I stopped doing this, she began asking people to repeat themselves and then gave her own answers. My attempt to protect her from awkward moments had also prevented her from taking part in the way she wanted.
The revised weekend was less impressive on paper. It was also the first time the visit felt shared. We still introduced Lina to places and people, but we explained the choices instead of treating them as obligations. By the end of the week, she suggested an activity neither of us had planned.
I had believed that being a good host meant filling every silence and every hour. I learned that a welcome can include information, invitations and help without becoming control.
Text Two: Hosting begins with listening
An original article by the coordinator of a student exchange.
Hosts often prepare enthusiastically because they want a visitor to feel valued. Plans are useful: a guest needs to know ordinary routines, meeting times, transport arrangements and whom to contact for help. Problems arise when useful information becomes a programme in which the visitor has no meaningful choice.
Offer invitations rather than a test of gratitude. Explain what an activity involves, how long it may take and whether there are alternatives. A guest may decline because of tiredness, private commitments, personal preference or a need for quiet time. Do not demand an explanation which turns every choice into a judgement on the host.
Avoid assuming that one visiting student represents a whole country, language or culture. Ask about the individual in front of you. At the same time, do not expect a guest to reveal personal information simply because the exchange is intended to encourage conversation. Interest should remain respectful.
Communication may take patience. Allow visitors time to answer, ask whether something needs to be explained again and avoid speaking on their behalf when they can respond for themselves. Help should increase a guest’s confidence and independence, not make the host the only person through whom every conversation must pass.
Privacy also matters. Ask before sharing photographs or personal details. Make sure the visitor knows where they can have some time alone and how to contact the exchange coordinator or another agreed adult. If a guest appears uncomfortable, check privately rather than making the concern into a public discussion. Serious concerns should be passed through the school’s agreed arrangements rather than managed secretly by students.
A successful exchange does not require constant entertainment or complete agreement. Hosts and visitors may have different preferences, and plans may change. What matters is that information is clear, choices are genuine and difficulties can be raised without embarrassment. The purpose is not to display the perfect weekend. It is to create the conditions in which two people can take part with consideration and curiosity.
Use ideas from both texts to answer this question.
Write a speech to students preparing to host visiting students during a school exchange. Recommend how to provide a thoughtful welcome while respecting visitors’ choices, privacy and independence.
You should include:
Think carefully about your purpose and the audience for whom you are writing.
212 exam-style questions on Edexcel B IGCSE English Language 2.4.2 Directed writing task based on source texts. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.