Text One: The stall beyond the pillar
An original account by a trader at a fictional community market.
For three years, I sold my printed cards from the same corner of Calder Hall. My table stood beyond a square pillar, near the back wall. The wall supported my display frames, and regular customers knew where to find me. I could unload, arrange the table and be ready in twenty minutes because every box had its place.
I had accepted that pitch when it was the only one available. What I had not noticed was how few visitors reached it. During one Saturday market, volunteers counted people moving through the hall. Fewer than half of those entering crossed the line between the front and rear aisles. Many bought a drink near the doors and turned back. Traders at the entrance believed that their higher sales proved their goods were more popular. From my corner, it was impossible to know whether visitors had rejected my cards or simply failed to see them.
The committee arranged a trial in which traders exchanged pitches. On my first morning beside the entrance, I answered more questions before midday than I usually answered during an entire market. I also sold all my lowest-priced prints. The result did not prove that I should own the entrance pitch, but it did show that position affected my opportunity to meet customers.
The trial created other problems. A pottery trader who normally unloaded beside a side door had to wheel heavy boxes through a public aisle when a delivery arrived late. Another trader was assigned a bay without the electrical socket needed for a small display light. Meanwhile, one of my regular customers searched my old corner, found no current market plan and assumed that I was absent.
At the next meeting, some traders wanted all the old positions restored. Others proposed drawing a different pitch number every week. Neither answer seemed fair. We needed to mark which bays had power, easy loading access or suitable walls, and traders needed to explain which features were essential rather than merely convenient. Pitches with similar facilities could then be shared by a draw or a planned rotation, with each arrangement lasting long enough to provide stability. Numbered bays and an accurate plan would help customers follow the changes.
Fairness would not mean making everyone carry boxes the same distance. It would mean removing advantages that had never been discussed while recognising the genuine differences between stalls.
Text Two: Plan the market before dividing it
An original article by the coordinator of the fictional community market.
A familiar pitch has practical value. Traders can prepare displays for a known space, and returning customers can go directly to the people they intend to visit. However, an arrangement made for convenience can gradually be treated as permanent ownership. If some parts of a hall receive much more passing trade than others, keeping every stall in place may preserve an advantage which was never awarded openly.
The solution is not to label one bay as the best and move everyone through it. A position beside the main doors may bring high footfall, but it may also be draughty or crowded. Some traders need a socket, a washable surface, extra width or access for heavy containers. Others may benefit from a quieter area where visitors can stop without blocking an aisle. Equal treatment begins with an accurate survey of the building, not with pretending that every pitch is identical.
Traders should describe their essential requirements and give reasons for them. Preferences can also be recorded, but they should not automatically determine the result. Once suitable groups of pitches have been identified, a ballot or rotation can distribute opportunities within each group. Allocations should last for a block of markets: constant movement wastes preparation time and makes traders difficult to locate.
Any new system should be tested over several market days. Coordinators can count how visitors move through the hall, ask whether they found the stalls they wanted and record problems with setting up or keeping aisles clear. Sales may provide useful evidence if traders choose to share it, but different products, prices and weather conditions mean that takings alone cannot prove that an allocation is fair.
Communication matters as much as the allocation itself. Every bay should have a number, and current plans should be displayed at the entrances. Traders should receive their positions before they arrive, while visitors should be told where stalls have moved. A clear directory can preserve the convenience of a fixed pitch without making any location permanent.
Finally, publish the criteria, provide a way to question a decision and review the system after the trial. A fair process cannot promise identical sales or satisfy every preference. It can make practical needs visible, share opportunities and allow decisions to be examined rather than inherited.
Use ideas from both texts to answer this question.
Write an article for the newsletter of a community market in which you recommend how stalls should be allocated. Use the situation described in the texts to consider the needs of traders and visitors and to propose a fair system.
You should include:
Think carefully about your purpose and the audience for whom you are writing.
212 exam-style questions on Edexcel B IGCSE English Language 2.4.2 Directed writing task based on source texts. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.