The key in the wrong box
Text One: an original account of sorting keys in a town hall maintenance cupboard.
The new key carried a white tag marked “SIDE DOOR”. Its metal caught the light and its ridged edge was clean. In the same tray lay an older key, spotted with green paint, its label hanging by one corner. It looked as though it had been forgotten rather than kept.
The caretaker had asked me to find the key for a door at the back of the building. I picked up the tagged one first. The handwriting was neat, the label was certain and the key fitted comfortably between my fingers. It seemed unnecessary to test anything else.
Mara watched me cross the courtyard. “Try the lock, not the label,” she said. The new key entered the keyhole without difficulty. It would not turn. I pushed harder, then withdrew it and examined its unmarked surface as if a fault might have appeared there.
The older key was less cooperative from the beginning. Its paint caught on the edge of the tray, and I had to wipe a smear from my thumb. When I put it into the lock, it stopped halfway. For a moment, both keys seemed to have failed in different ways.
Mara turned the older key over. A shallow notch ran along one side, almost hidden beneath the paint. She adjusted it, tried again and heard the bolt move inside the door. The sound was small, but it changed the courtyard. The closed door no longer looked like a blank wall; it had become an entrance.
Back in the cupboard, I returned the clean key to its labelled box. The older one went into a drawer with no label at all. Its paint, its damaged tag and its hidden notch made a less attractive record, but it was the only one that had told the truth about the door.
How does the writer explore the difference between looking suitable and being useful?
Support your answer with close reference to the text, including brief quotations.
324 exam-style questions on Edexcel B IGCSE English Language 2.3 Section A: Reading, covering 2.3.5 AO1 in Section A, 2.3.6 AO2 in Section A, and 2.3.7 AO3 in Section A. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.