Where the water was
Text One: an original opinion column.
At noon, the square is quieter than it has any right to be. The old circular basin remains, but it has been filled with pale gravel and six boxed shrubs. Where water used to climb and collapse, the shrubs stand at attention. A receipt skates across the gravel, making the only movement.
Last summer, the fountain never allowed the square to settle. Water slapped the stone, hissed in the wind and scattered light across the paving. Children approached with both hands held out; office workers curved around the spray with their lunches; pigeons conducted their serious arguments along the rim. Even those who complained about getting wet had been given something to complain about together.
Ask residents what has disappeared and each supplies a different answer. The baker misses “the sound before the shops opened”. A bicycle courier remembers a cool place to stop. One child says simply, “It made rainbows.” These are not grand claims, but together they reveal how many versions of the square could exist in the same space.
The decision paper speaks in tidy nouns: “maintenance”, “leakage”, “liability”. In its table, the fountain becomes a neat line of expense. Numbers can record the cost of pumping water; they cannot record the moment when a stranger moves along a bench so that somebody else can see it.
The paper also asks how often the fountain was “used”. That is a blunt verb for what happened there. We did not use the fountain as we use a ticket machine. It interrupted our routes. It lent noise to empty mornings. It gave people who had nothing else in common a reason to face the same direction.
Now most pedestrians cross the square diagonally and leave. The shrubs are decoration; the fountain was punctuation. One occupies the centre. The other made us pause.
Yesterday, rain collected briefly on top of the gravel. A girl crouched beside the basin and stirred the shallow water with one finger. For a few seconds, the square flashed again. Then the drain swallowed the puddle, and she waited beside the stones.
How does the writer use language and structure to show that removing the fountain has been a loss to the town?
Support your answer with close reference to the text, including brief quotations.
324 exam-style questions on Edexcel B IGCSE English Language 2.3 Section A: Reading, covering 2.3.5 AO1 in Section A, 2.3.6 AO2 in Section A, and 2.3.7 AO3 in Section A. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.