The building we would lose
Text One: A screen worth keeping
An original letter by a resident opposing cinema demolition.
I am writing about the proposal to demolish the Regal. The report calls it an outdated building on a valuable site. I have no argument with the second description. I am less sure why the first should bring the discussion to an end.
My first visit was with my mother. I remember the red stair carpet more clearly than the film. Years later, I took my own children up those stairs, carrying drinks with lids which never seemed to fit. The building’s value is not that every detail is beautiful. It is that different parts of our lives have happened in the same place.
I know that memory will not repair the leaking roof. The owners have bills, and the council cannot promise money it does not possess. But has every possible use been examined? The hall could host local performances. Part of the foyer could be rented. Other suggestions may be better than mine. A site described only as valuable can quickly become a site valued only for what replaces it.
The proposed flats may be needed. People who remember the cinema should not pretend that remembering gives us an exclusive claim on the future. Still, future residents will live in a town whose shared places are being decided now.
Before accepting that the Regal has reached the end of its usefulness, please show us what keeping it would require. Let the choice be between examined possibilities, not between a developer’s drawing and a memory which has been dismissed as sentiment.
Text Two: After the last showing
An original opinion article by a younger resident.
I have never seen a film at the Regal. Its doors were locked before I was old enough to go alone. For me, the familiar view is a poster case filled with faded paper and weeds growing where the ticket queue once stood.
When people speak about losing the cinema, I hear something worth respecting. A town should not forget the places which brought people together. But I would like to ask who is brought together by the building now. Passing a closed entrance is not the same as having a place to meet.
I share a room with my brother. The new flats might not be affordable for us, and the developer’s promise of a lively ground-floor space deserves careful questioning. I am not arguing that any new building is automatically better. I am arguing that keeping an empty one is not automatically a community victory.
If there is a realistic plan to reopen the Regal for public use, let us see its costs and who would run it. If there is not, could the replacement include a room which people can actually book without spending a fortune? Preserve the sign, record the stories and make a decent place beneath them.
I do not want to defeat the people who loved the old cinema. I want some of the warmth they describe to exist in a place I can enter. A town’s memory should open a door for its next generation, not merely explain why the door used to matter.
Compare how the writers present their ideas and perspectives about the future of the disused cinema.
Support your answer with detailed references to both texts, including brief quotations.
324 exam-style questions on Edexcel B IGCSE English Language 2.3 Section A: Reading, covering 2.3.5 AO1 in Section A, 2.3.6 AO2 in Section A, and 2.3.7 AO3 in Section A. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.