A psychologist wants to test the hypothesis that critical feedback reduces the time adults persist with a difficult puzzle. Seventy-two adult volunteers are randomly allocated to one of two groups. One researcher tests the critical-feedback group in a room at 26 °C, gives each participant the same scripted criticism and then presents an impossible puzzle. A different researcher tests the neutral-feedback group in a room at 19 °C, gives the same neutral statement to each participant and presents a difficult but solvable puzzle. The dependent variable is the number of seconds before the participant stops working, up to a maximum of 10 minutes.
The volunteers consent to a study of puzzle solving and are told that the feedback is a genuine assessment of their ability. In fact, it is decided by their allocated condition. No debrief is given, and several participants report feeling embarrassed by the criticism. Participants may leave at any time and request removal of their data. All results are stored under code numbers.
Evaluate the validity of this investigation and the way its ethical issues have been addressed.
96 exam-style questions on AQA GCSE Psychology 1.4 Research methods, covering 1.4.1 Formulation of testable hypotheses, 1.4.2 Types of variable, 1.4.3 Sampling methods, 1.4.4 Experimental method and designs, 1.4.5 Types of experiment, 1.4.6 Non-experimental research methods, 1.4.7 Correlation, 1.4.8 Research procedures, 1.4.9 Planning and conducting research, and 1.4.10 Ethical considerations. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.