A psychologist wants to investigate how often pupils put their lunch waste into the correct recycling bin when no adult prompts them. Two procedures are piloted. In each pilot, two observers use the same behavioural categories to classify 100 waste-disposal events.
| Procedure | Setting and participants' awareness | Consent and handling of data | Waste put in the correct bin | Inter-observer agreement |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| A | The usual school dining hall at lunchtime. Pupils do not know that hidden video is being used. | Pupils and parents are not asked for consent. Recordings retain recognisable faces. | 58 out of 100 events | 90% |
| B | A classroom arranged with the same recycling bins. Pupils know the aim and can see the observers. | Pupils give assent, parents give consent, code numbers are used and pupils may withdraw their data. | 82 out of 100 events | 95% |
Discuss which procedure the psychologist should use for the main study. Refer to the pilot data and suggest any changes that should be made to the chosen procedure.
96 exam-style questions on AQA GCSE Psychology 1.4 Research methods, covering 1.4.1 Formulation of testable hypotheses, 1.4.2 Types of variable, 1.4.3 Sampling methods, 1.4.4 Experimental method and designs, 1.4.5 Types of experiment, 1.4.6 Non-experimental research methods, 1.4.7 Correlation, 1.4.8 Research procedures, 1.4.9 Planning and conducting research, and 1.4.10 Ethical considerations. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.