A psychologist investigates whether lighting affects proofreading. The hypothesis is that office workers will identify more errors under bright lighting than under dim lighting.
Forty adult office workers are randomly allocated to two groups. Both groups proofread the same passage, which contains 30 deliberate errors, and hear the same recorded instructions. The bright-light group is tested at 09:00 in a quiet meeting room and completes a three-minute practice task first. The dim-light group is tested at 16:00 in a room next to a busy staff kitchen and does not complete a practice task.
The results are shown in the table.
| Lighting condition | Mean number of errors identified out of 30 |
|---|---|
| Bright | 22.6 |
| Dim | 17.1 |
The psychologist concludes that bright lighting causes better proofreading. The workers had been told by their managers that participation was compulsory and that they could not stop once the task began. Afterwards, every worker's name and score were sent to their manager.
An ethics committee is considering a proposal to repeat the study using the same procedure.
Using the results and details of the procedure, evaluate the psychologist's conclusion and the proposal to repeat the study unchanged.
96 exam-style questions on AQA GCSE Psychology 1.4 Research methods, covering 1.4.1 Formulation of testable hypotheses, 1.4.2 Types of variable, 1.4.3 Sampling methods, 1.4.4 Experimental method and designs, 1.4.5 Types of experiment, 1.4.6 Non-experimental research methods, 1.4.7 Correlation, 1.4.8 Research procedures, 1.4.9 Planning and conducting research, and 1.4.10 Ethical considerations. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.