An automated analyser checks an unlabelled sodium halide solution. The solution is sodium chloride, sodium bromide or sodium iodide.
The analyser tests separate portions of the solution.
| Halogen solution added | Colour before mixing | Colour after mixing |
|---|---|---|
| chlorine water | very pale green | brown |
| bromine water | orange | brown |
The analyser reports that the solution is sodium bromide because both tests produced a coloured halogen.
Which evaluation of this report is correct?
The report is incorrect; the solution is sodium chloride, because neither added halogen can displace chlorine
The report is incorrect; the solution is sodium iodide, because both added halogens displace iodine
The report is correct, because displaced bromine forms a brown solution in both tests
The halide cannot be identified, because both portions of the solution had the same final colour
100 exam-style questions on Edexcel GCSE Chemistry 7.2 Group 7, covering 7.2.1 Physical properties of the halogens, 7.2.2 Reactions of the halogens, 7.2.3 Relative reactivity and displacement reactions of the halogens, and 7.2.4 Halogen displacement as a redox reaction. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.