Two students each react 0.050 g of magnesium with hydrochloric acid and collect about 50 cm³ of hydrogen in a gas syringe.
Both students wear eye protection and make sure that there are no naked flames in the room. The table shows their planned procedures.
| Procedure | Hydrochloric acid | Volume of acid | Time taken to collect the hydrogen | Apparatus | Gas syringe plunger |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| A | dilute; labelled irritant | 40 cm³ | 180 s | not clamped | moves freely |
| B | concentrated; labelled corrosive | 10 cm³ | 45 s | clamped | sometimes sticks |
Evaluate the risks in procedures A and B and suggest a safer method. Include a judgement about whether the remaining risk would be low enough for the investigation to be carried out.
102 exam-style questions on Edexcel GCSE Chemistry 1.1 Formulae, equations and hazards, covering 1.1.1 Formulae, word and balanced equations, 1.1.2 Balanced ionic equations, and 1.1.3 Hazard symbols and risk in practical work. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.