Skip to content
MathsGenie logo
Quick links
Open app

Course home

  1. A Level
  2. Economics Edexcel A
  3. Question bank

3.4 Market structures

EasyMediumHard
1234567891011121314151617181920212223242526272829303132333435363738394041424344
Question 42

Figure 2: Average Electric Vehicle Pay-As-You-Go (PAYG) Rapid Charging Tariff compared to Wholesale Electricity Cost (p per kWh)

YearVoltCharge PAYGGridPower PAYGElectroDrive PAYGWholesale Electricity Cost*
201235p33p34p12.0p
201338p35p36p11.5p
201442p38p39p10.8p
201545p41p42p10.0p
201649p44p45p9.2p
201753p47p48p8.5p
201857p51p52p7.8p
201961p55p56p7.0p
202066p59p60p6.2p
202171p63p64p5.5p
202276p67p68p4.8p

*Wholesale Electricity Cost – the average baseload wholesale electricity price allocated per kWh delivered.

Extract B

Electra Group profits surge

Electra Group, the parent company of VoltCharge, reported a substantial rise in operating profits following its acquisition of the smart route-planning and billing app "AmpFlow" in late 2019. This merger consolidated VoltCharge's market share in key transit corridors to a dominant 32%. Operating profits for VoltCharge's highway rapid-charging division reached £142 million for the financial year ending 2022.

The Chief Executive commented: "By integrating AmpFlow’s proprietary pre-booking algorithms with VoltCharge's physical infrastructure, we have locked in premium fleet contracts. This technology-retail synergy allows us to offer bundled premium subscriptions, securing steady high-margin revenue streams as EV adoption accelerates."

Extract C

Regulator proposes price caps on rapid charging networks

The national infrastructure regulator is preparing to intervene in the electric vehicle charging market, proposing price caps on standard pay-as-you-go (PAYG) tariffs. The investigation highlighted 'exploitative pricing of captive motorway travelers.' The regulator estimated that a price cap could save EV drivers up to £180 annually.

The regulator stepped in because PAYG charging tariffs have more than doubled over the past decade. This upward trend persisted despite charging network operators benefiting from a persistent, long-term decline in wholesale electricity contract costs. Many drivers have limited choice when charging on long journeys, with over 65% of regional highway chargers operated solely by VoltCharge.

A spokesperson for the regulator stated: "A lack of local competition and high consumer search/transaction costs on long journeys have allowed VoltCharge and other key players to systematically increase retail margins without facing competitive pressure. Over 75% of non-subscription drivers simply use the nearest available rapid charger regardless of price, creating highly price-inelastic demand pools."

Discuss one likely reason for the rise in Electra Group's profit (Figure 2, Extracts B and C). Use a cost and revenue diagram to support your answer.

Monopoly Cost and Revenue Diagram

[12]

3.4 Market structures Questions

  1. A Level
  2. /Economics
  3. /3.4 Market structures