Skip to content
MathsGenie logo
Open app

Course home

  1. A Level
  2. Economics AQA
  3. Question bank

1.1 Economic methodology and the economic problem

EasyMediumHard
12
Question 1

Context 1: THE GLOBAL CONTEXT

Extract B: Phosphate Mining and Global Food Security

Global agricultural yields rely heavily on over 240 million tonnes of phosphate rock extracted annually to manufacture synthetic fertilizers. The vast majority of the world's easily accessible phosphate reserves are concentrated in Morocco and the Western Sahara. Industry analysts emphasize that these high-grade rock deposits are a 'finite resource' (line 4). However, the intensive chemical processing required to convert raw phosphate into agricultural-grade diammonium phosphate (DAP) releases highly acidic phosphogypsum waste and consumes immense volumes of scarce local groundwater. In 2027, environmental monitoring agencies warned that unrestrained dumping of this radioactive and acidic byproduct is destroying coastal marine ecosystems and contaminating regional aquifers. If international bodies enforce strict ecological waste-disposal and water-recycling mandates, fertilizer manufacturers may face soaring operating expenses.

Agricultural lobbying groups argue that implementing rigorous ecological standards on phosphate processing is 'harmful to industrial competitiveness' (line 12). They contend that mandating advanced waste-treatment facilities dramatically inflates production costs, raises global fertilizer prices, and puts domestic exporters at a severe disadvantage against foreign producers operating in countries with laxer environmental protocols. Conversely, environmental economists argue that failing to regulate the industry will result in catastrophic externalities, including the permanent destruction of local fishing industries and tourism. As the global population expands, balancing immediate agricultural productivity with the preservation of vital ecosystems remains a critical policy dilemma.

Explain what is meant by a 'finite resource' (Extract B, line 4) and analyse why it might be argued that environmental regulation of phosphate mining is 'harmful to industrial competitiveness' (Extract B, line 12).

[10]

1.1 Economic methodology and the economic problem Questions

  1. A Level
  2. /Economics
  3. /1.1 Economic methodology and the economic problem