Skip to content

Course home

Revision guides·6.3.2 Argument for learning theory
Sign up

6.3.2 Argument for learning theory

Goldstein et al. and Social Feedback

  1. Goldstein et al. tested whether caregivers' responses could shape the sounds young babies make.
  2. When mothers reacted warmly and promptly to babbling, their babies babbled more and produced more advanced, speech-like sounds.
  3. That warm response works as reinforcement, so the finding backs the learning theory of language.
Key Idea
  • Social feedback from a caregiver acts as reinforcement for a baby's early sounds.
  • Because the feedback changes what the baby produces, the environment is clearly shaping language.

What the Study Found

  1. In one group, mothers responded to each babble at once with a smile, a touch or by moving closer.
  2. In a comparison group, the babies got the same warm reactions but at random times, not tied to their sounds.
  3. Only the babies whose feedback was tied to their babbling produced more, and more mature, sounds.
Example
  • Picture a baby in a high chair who says "ba-ba" and instantly gets a grin and a cuddle.
  • That well-timed response is positive reinforcement, so the baby babbles again.
  • The same grin given at random moments does not push the sounds forward.

Why It Backs the Learning Theory

  1. The theory predicts that reinforcement should change how children speak, and that is exactly what happened.
  2. Because only the well-timed feedback worked, the change was down to reinforcement, not just hearing an adult voice.
  3. This shows positive reinforcement helps early language, which is the learning theory's central claim.
Note
  • For this argument you are marked on the results and what they show, not the aim or procedure.
  • Say the well-timed feedback produced more advanced sounds, then name reinforcement as the process.

Using the Study in the Exam

  1. State the finding in one line: well-timed caregiver feedback made babies produce more advanced sounds.
  2. Name the process, reinforcement, rather than just retelling the study.
  3. Conclude that language is shaped by the environment, which is the learning theory's central claim.
Self review
  • What happened to the babies who got well-timed feedback?
  • Why did feedback given at random times not have the same effect?
  • Which learning process does the feedback illustrate?
  • Why does the study support a nurture account of language?
PreviousNext

How was this guide?

Teach Genie

Review 6.3.2 Argument for learning theory by teaching Genie

Teach it back in your own words, spot gaps, and remember it better.

Start teaching
Genie and Baby Genie

Lesson

Recap your knowledge with an interactive lesson

7 minute activity

Start lesson

Learning theory argues that language is shaped by the environment. Caregiver responses can act as reinforcement, increasing the likelihood that a baby will repeat particular sounds.

Goldstein et al. tested this argument by examining whether mothers' responses to babbling affected the babies' later vocalisations. The key issue is whether feedback was linked to the baby's sound or happened randomly.

Questions

Put it into practice with exam-style questions

7 exam-style questions

Practice questions

Question 1

3 marks

Two community music groups for babies tried different ways of responding to the babies' babbling for four weeks. In Group A, the leader smiled and spoke warmly to a baby as soon as it babbled. In Group B, the leader gave the same warm smiles and words, but at random moments that were not linked to the babies' babbling. The table shows the mean number of speech-like sounds made by each baby during a 10-minute session.

GroupMean number of speech-like sounds per baby at the startMean number of speech-like sounds per baby after four weeks
A813
B89

Flashcards

Remember key concepts with flashcards

20 flashcards

Practice flashcards

What happened when mothers responded warmly and promptly to babies’ babbling?

6.3.2 Argument for learning theory Revision Guide

  1. IGCSE
  2. /Psychology
  3. /6.3.2 Argument for learning theory

Revision notes for CIE IGCSE Psychology 6.3.2 Argument for learning theory: explanations and worked examples.

More revision guides